did you know that the best men were sent to a new job first and they stayed to the end before going back to the union hall for another job. Guess who were the last to be hired onto a job and the first to be sent back to the hall...the know-it-alls that had more mouth than fortitude.
You are describing union corruption. I have witnessed this first hand. My father was a union man for 40 years.
He was a skilled hard worker and competent, but the local business agent didn't like him. I never learned why.
As he would get near the top of the board, waiting to be sent out on a job, some shuffling invariably went on. The BA's son (or friends) would always somehow luck out and get sent to a 1+ year job; my Dad would often get sent out on a job that lasted 1 day. After 1 day of work he went back to the bottom of the board to sit it out-- sometimes that wait stretched for months.
To provide for our family, he often had to pull a travel card and go work out of town where work was aplenty. Leaving our family behind-- sometimes for months.
When he retired, the union disallowed work he had accrued while using a travel card. Since he had traveled often needing to find work, it cut 9 years of service off his retirement pension.
If alive today, my Dad would defend the union. But as part of the family often left behind, I'm more than skeptical about their value. I've seen the seedy underbellly first hand.
Oddly enough, when I threw a retirement party for my Dad, the BA showed up and was all smiles ...