1705 hydraulic oil change

   / 1705 hydraulic oil change
  • Thread Starter
#11  
Service tech for massy im sure would indeed make it more dramatic than it should be. We are certainly not the only ones with the thought process. When i order fluids from my salesman he never asks how many hours are on my machine. I would think they would ask to keep track but they don't. I did ask him how Massey was when dealing with a warranty issue. Of course he gave them a thumbs up but i have seen some threads on here where warranty work was declined. Of course in those cases there is always two sides to the story. Was the operator abusing the machine with out knowing he was. Or was it due to a simple failure.


I agree, I did mine at 120 hours, 50 seems a little much. All my fluids came out looking like new with very little metal in it.

The service guy asked me how many hours on my machine when I went to buy the fluid and filters, I told him 120, he acted like the world was going to come to and end, turns out the guy doesn't have a clue about much of anything after talking with him for ten minutes..
 
   / 1705 hydraulic oil change #12  
A UOA Lab will tell you when it is time to change lubricants, gear oils, engine oils and coolants.
 
   / 1705 hydraulic oil change #13  
Very few tractors require a change of the hydraulic fluid at 50 hours, because it is not necessary. Filters, yes, but not fluid. Some people feel better doing it, which is fine. I absolutely would not criticize anyone who follows the proper procedure and only changes filters at 50 hours.

The other option, if you really want to examine the fluid and or access screens or other parts, is to do what most equipment shops would do during a repair -- drain the fluid into clean pails, then reuse it. You can buy very inexpensive (25 cents or less) cone filters that will filter the fluid as you put it back in the tractor. If the fluid has low hours on it (most don't require replacement until 300-400 hours) then it's a true waste to dispose of it.
 
   / 1705 hydraulic oil change
  • Thread Starter
#14  
Im not criticizing anyone it just seems odd to me. given the advancements in lubricating properties and engineering in general. I would not have thought it would come to this.
 
   / 1705 hydraulic oil change #15  
Very few tractors require a change of the hydraulic fluid at 50 hours, because it is not necessary. Filters, yes, but not fluid. Some people feel better doing it, which is fine. I absolutely would not criticize anyone who follows the proper procedure and only changes filters at 50 hours.

The other option, if you really want to examine the fluid and or access screens or other parts, is to do what most equipment shops would do during a repair -- drain the fluid into clean pails, then reuse it. You can buy very inexpensive (25 cents or less) cone filters that will filter the fluid as you put it back in the tractor. If the fluid has low hours on it (most don't require replacement until 300-400 hours) then it's a true waste to dispose of it.

I suspect that most equipment manufacturers recommend changing fluids at earlier than needed intervals to avoid warranty issues as well as generate revenue for the dealer.

Ask yourself, "What wears out in tractor hydraulic fluid"?

That depends on many factors such as the fluid itself (the blend), the severity of service, age of the fluid, moisture, shear and other factors. The fluid is there mostly to lubricate pump and gearbox parts, provide cooling and corrosion inhibition as well as provide the hydraulic pressure and flow to move the elements in the system (cylinders, hydraulic motors, etc.).

There are no combustion by-products as in engine oil therefore, the TBN and NOACK remain stable for long periods. If you are concerned about the wear of the parts contacted by the fluid, send a sample to a lab for a UOA. That's the only way to tell if your fluid is worn out, if there is abnormal wear or your filtration is inadequate.
 
   / 1705 hydraulic oil change #16  
s219;5340744is The other option said:
While this may be fine for us DIYers, the shop looses the profit on new fluid if they follow the drain/reuse procedure. Before I would replace $100.00 worth of hydraulic oil, I would send off a sample for a UOA. Costs $30.00 bucks to determine if your tractor is wearing out, if your filtration is adequate, if your fluid is worn out, if you are risking corrosion, the fluid has been overheated, etc.

If you are really interested in learning about lubricants, filters and other aspects of lubrication, go to

Heavy and Industrial Lubrication - Bob Is The Oil Guy
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2022 Forest River Cherokee Grey Wolf 26BRB Patriotic Edition 32ft. T/A Travel Trailer (A51694)
2022 Forest River...
John Deere XUV560E 4x4 Utility Cart (A50322)
John Deere XUV560E...
New Holland 479 Haybine (A50774)
New Holland 479...
Mi-T-M AS6-HE15-120M 175 PSI Air Compressor (A50322)
Mi-T-M...
2010 Ford Edge SE SUV (A51694)
2010 Ford Edge SE...
ATTENTION! PLEASE READ (A50121)
ATTENTION! PLEASE...
 
Top