scesnick
Welcome brother!
I hunt on my property near Morgantown, WV and like you have killed so many deer with the bow that I have lost count. Actually, I've never kept track except for the year.
Scents are for sure a sometimes thing. But, I can tell you that Tink's has resulted in the biggest buck I've bow shot. He was judged at 7 1/2 yrs old and came in about 1430 hrs downwind of my scent station. He stopped about 75 yds away, lifted his head to scent, doubled back and ran right into the scent station where I killed him.
Had the same thing happen at magic hour as a buck made a scrape about 25 yds away, but unseen as it was unbelievably thick. He headed out to the field and I didn't even pick up my bow until I saw him stop, look my way, lip curl and turn around and came downhill, turned right, and came right into my tree where I killed him. As soon as he did the lip curl, I knew what was going to happen and immediately picked up my bow. Without the Tinks, he would have just continued out to the field and even though very close, it was too thick to shoot past 5 yds.
Other times, they pay no attention whatsoever to it. I've had it work great about 6 time and I'll take that. Since you are an experience bowhunter, you surely know that nothing is always this or that.
Regarding my scent, I play the wind as it is the most important factor in getting within bow range of a deer. Coyotes are even tougher than deer are in that regards. Thermals, eddy currents and back drafts always present problems that we often fail to recognize as we can't "see" where our scent goes. The bottom line is we just have to do the best we can and try to remain downwind. Say......how many times have deer shown up behind your stand where you never expected them to come from? That's a retorical question as we know it happens too often.
I have always tried to hide from from my hunting dogs during training to keep them closer and to check on me for directions and have a lot of experience on what their capabilities are and you CAN NOT fool them! I suggest getting into your most scent free condition as possible and try it with you own dog and see how lquickly it takes even a house dog to find you.
We aren't hunting in the boreal forests of Canada where the deer have never smelled a human. Where we hunt, they know the sounds of tractors, barking dogs, gun shots, traffic etc. and are not especially disturbed by smelling people. It just makes me crack up at the lengths some people will go to, to remove what can't be done. It psyches them completely out if one thing is wrong with their regiment and ruins their hunt. I believe obsessive compulsive is the term used to explain how some folks can take an enjoyable sport that is sooooo much fun and turn it into a "life and death" competitive activity that might cause them to compromise their ethics.
BTW, i did score on a old cow mamma after the six of them milled around me for 20 minutes. Cracked her with a double lunger at 10 ft. Couldn't have been prouder. Those alpha does are tough under any conditions with a bow, and with all those eyes and noses with her, I felt pretty good about that. I was hunting on the ground and yes.......I even smoke and didn't even have camo on let alone scent free camo. It can be done.
Will be in camp for the entire 2 weeks of gun season next week. Best of luck to you and I hope you bag the big one.