Don't worry about the different spirals and a tight connection.
The problem you had was caused by digging a narrow trench to put the original culvert into. Fill material could not get under the bottom half of the culvert. So it created a vacancy that eventually filled itself. It did so by crushing the culvert.
Never bury a culvert in a tight fitting trench. Always have at least 50% of the culvert width of open trench on each side. So for a 36" culvert you needed at least a 72" trench. This allows fill material to be place under the bottom half of the culvert. Even with this situation you will still see some "egg shaping" of the culvert. But it won't affect the volume flow of the culvert.
Fill material is irrelevant. I never use anything but dirt.
I work for a Township and over the past 25 years have buried hundreds of road culverts. I've never used special fill material. I always want an open trench so I can get material under the culvert. Once I get some under it, I pack the snot out of it with the Road Grader. It will always settle. You can't stop that. Just expect it.
Good luck with your project.![]()
I think you hit it on the nose!! The problem happened orginally as we could not find any way to stop the flow of water when installing the culverts.The correct way would have been to dig a 200' ditch along side of the permanent culvert,which would have been a disaster, but !!
If I had to guess I would say there was approx 6'' of water to deal with while installing. When installing it the second time we still had some water but less and we did try to lay class 5 under the culvert but not sure how much of a void is under it?
So I guess time will tell.
Thanks For Your Help