Beltzington
Platinum Member
I would go with a grade 2, 3/8, and if you start shearing bolts under normal load then go up to grade 5.
Concur, bolts are cheap, belts and gears not so much. Besides look at it as your daily exercise, cardio and legs getting on and off the tractor and flexibility and arms turning the PTO shaft to align the holes. Also, after mowing the field a couple times you will have found and eliminated most the obstructions, I havn't sheared a grade 2 bolt in at least a dozen mowings.