Although I have no experience with the liners that you mentioned....I can also vouch for the Line-X. It is holding up extremely well in my F150.
I had Rhino on my truck and I really liked it. It was durable, but what I like better about it than Line-X is the non-skid factor. When you put something on the Rhino, it stays where you put it and doesn't slide...at all! The Line-X liners I have seen are a little harder and tend to allow things to slide around a little more.
Thanks for the replies guys.
I called Rhino today. The have 2 liners. The one is put on up to 1/8'' thick and $450. The other is put on up to 1/4" and has rubber in it. She said it was more skid resistant than the cheaper. The charge $25 extra is you have a tail gate step.
I had Rhino on my truck and I really liked it. It was durable, but what I like better about it than Line-X is the non-skid factor. When you put something on the Rhino, it stays where you put it and doesn't slide...at all! The Line-X liners I have seen are a little harder and tend to allow things to slide around a little more.
Funny, we are exact opposites! I have a bad back, and detest climbing in and out of the bed to retrieve the toolbox that is stuck like glue to the liner. The Line-X isn't slick like the plastic liner inserts, but does allow you to slide items with some effort.