Best wrench brand I can afford?

   / Best wrench brand I can afford? #21  
I started out with Craftsman, but I've broken too many of their sockets and socket wrenches to mess with them anymore. I've been buying Kobalt from Lowes for my smaller sockets and wrenches for the last decade and going to Tractor Supply for my really big wrenches. I haven't broke any of those big wrenches, and a few I've ground down to get them to fit where I needed them. I've also found Mastercraft to be very good, along with Proto for my impact sockets. Napa also has a nice set of tools that have held up over the years.

Eddie
 
   / Best wrench brand I can afford? #22  
Lot's of good advice here but consider WHAT, WHERE and WHEN (and how often) you will be wrenching. You list a "Kabota MX4800" as your tractor (must be one of those Chinese clones :) ).

If you are going to be wrenching on that, in the field (replace a hydraulic line for example), you'll need something you can lose. If you are wrenching in the shop (changing a rear tire for example) you'll need something big. If you are going to have several projects going on at once in separate areas you'll need multiple sets of some tools.

I have found ACE hardware brand to be a good choice, on the open box end wrenches, I like SK brand, but the cost of them is out of my reach, and I have put the ACE brand, in the tractors, and in the wood shop, and in the welding truck, also a few sets of 3/8 sockets kits, with both metric and sae,

the local sears will not honor the warranty but ace will hand one a new socket set or wrench with out problems,

As BHD wrote
in the tractors, and in the wood shop,
saves a LOT of time if you don't have to walk a mile to get that 1/2" ratchet w/ the 9/16 socket.

Craftsman usually offers a 'mechanics set' from 1/4 to 1/2 drive, with 6 and twelve points in a 4 drawer case for ~$200. Nice thing is there are usually fairly close places to exchange/repair when something breaks. They aren't the finest, but are very good. Deep socket variety and larger ones (like on tractors) are usually not in sets, unless you get a really big one with many of the tools you already have. I have a cheapo 3/4 drive set that appears pretty regularly when the tractor is the project. Ugly, cheap, overly heavy and thick--haven't broke one yet though. Stanley and Channelock sets have been good (big box store sets), but are for smaller stuff--light automotive and assembly. They do round and polish the handles--I do like that--if I were turning wrenches for a living, I'd spring for the comfort.
I also started out with Craftsman in the 1960's, and have returned about 3 ratchets, with increasing difficulty. I also bought an HF 3/4 socket set for my tractor when I needed it. Craftsman (even on ebay) wants about $400, HF $60 w/ 20% off.

Harbor freight stuff works just fine for a home mechanic. I use alot of their stuff. Their impact sockets, wrenches, and the more pricey ratchets are good. But avoid their channel locks, pliers, and crescent wrenches.

Best crescent I have is a fuller, made in Japan. No idea where I got that one though.
I agree w/ HF for that, I've an HF long handled wrench set I've been wailing on with a 3lb sledge w/ no problem. Their impacts are not clearly labeled though, which is a pain.


New Craftsman wrench sets and socket sets can be purchased on eBay for 30% of the cost in stores.

However, today's Craftsman, like Sears itself, is not what it was.

Sears is expiring. In bankruptcy warranties are voided.

I agree, don't depend on a "lifetime warranty".

I started out with Craftsman, but I've broken too many of their sockets and socket wrenches to mess with them anymore. I've been buying Kobalt from Lowes for my smaller sockets and wrenches for the last decade and going to Tractor Supply for my really big wrenches. I haven't broke any of those big wrenches, and a few I've ground down to get them to fit where I needed them. I've also found Mastercraft to be very good, along with Proto for my impact sockets. Napa also has a nice set of tools that have held up over the years.

Eddie

And when on sale Kobalt often matches HF's regular price.

In summary, plan on getting multiple sets of some base packages, like SAE/metric open ends and I think HF does well with these. IF you have an HF near you. Meridith doesn't seem to have one. Kobalt does pretty good. Just remember if you spend big money on a few Snap On quality tools and you DON'T have the tool available it's useless.

Today I've got to buy another 1/2" impact wrench because I'm wrenching in Mississippi and my 1/2 inch is in Virginia.
 
   / Best wrench brand I can afford? #23  
Just so yall know; Husky (Home depot) is made by Stanley, and when you call the warranty number they answer "Stanley works", I'm about 85% sure that Kobalt is Craftsman.

The harbor freight impacts sockets and there "pro" wrenches are at least equal in strength to craftsman. As others mentioned, the polish and weight might not be as good.

I'm in a similar position; I have most of what I need, but it's mixed, in organized, gathered over time; and one day I would like to get an entire "set", but that's a ways off.
 
   / Best wrench brand I can afford? #24  
Used to be that Snap-On with their flank drive was the best, but the patent ran out years ago and now everybody uses a flank drive. Mac seems to have the best metal in their impact sockets.

That said, Northern isn't too bad and insofar as sets go, I don't think you'll go wrong purchasing a big 200+ tool set from channel-loc, craftsman, or wherever.

On my tractor the largest wrenches I need are on hydraulic fittings. Although some of it is metric, at a certain point SAE sizes fit good enough. For example: 22mm is 7/8ths and so on. My wrenches go up to 2" in size and I have multiples below 1-1/4".
 
   / Best wrench brand I can afford? #25  
I have mostly SK in 1/4, 3/8, & 1/2 drive and two sets of their combination wrenches - one metric & one SAE.
They weren't cheap, 39 years ago, when I started buying them, and the prices, now, seem very high, but they have proven very well made.

When I got my first, very used, front wheel drive car, in the 80's, I learned the new pleasure of changing front wheel hub bearings & CV joints. I was a student at the time and couldn't afford the required, huge, metric socket & ratchet in SK, so I got the HF 3/4" socket set and a 3/4" HF torque wrench, which have both been excellent values. I've used the 3/4" drive socket & breaker bar with a six foot pipe cheater bar to remove the blades on a brush hog and was very glad to have them when I needed them.

My favorites wrenches are a set of Blackhawk long pattern box ends that I've had since I started buying the SKs.
They just feel great as you apply more & more force on a stubborn fastener. Just the right amount of flex.

I also keep 2 sets of Fuller small wrenches, one metric & one SAE, in my tackle box toolkit for quick jobs.
A 16" cheater bar, made of 1" EMT and slightly flattened on one end, is also in that toolbox, and I haven't broken a Fuller, yet.
 
   / Best wrench brand I can afford? #26  
I am a master mechanic. I started with craftsman and Chinese stuff bought at the local stores to fill my box cheap. As time went on they were almost all replaced with snap on. I still have some craftsman in tools that I don't use much.

As others have said, buy 6 point and 12 point sockets in short and deep variety's. If you cant afford them buy mid length and just buy the deep socks you need. I almost always grab the mid length, wish I would have bought them sooner. Buy your combination wrenchs in 12 point.

Gearwrench is gaining popularity and even has their own tool trucks now.

My 1/2 stuff is Taiwanese NAPA and i have never had to warranty any of them. A couple swivels are starting to wear, but after 10 years of heavy use. ( think 60 hours a week 50 weeks a year ) And I neck up and down using the 1/4 on a 1/2 gun and vice versa with and without several long extensions.

Buy QUALITY air tools. You get what you pay for.

I bought almost all of my tools used of the tool truck for a fraction of new. I don't care if it is scratched, I am going to use it. Some mechanics replace stuff due to scratching, flash rust, and grease marks. None of that is a warranty issue, nor does it affect the tool, but they like them like new and are willing to pay for it. I am happy to buy it.

Stop a tool truck, stop by the closest shop to your house / farm and ask for the local tool reps number with the best reputation. Call the guy, explain your situation, see if he will let you start an account and come to you once a week / month or meet him at where ever.

Either way, put every one away when your done and you will never have to buy another one.
 
   / Best wrench brand I can afford? #27  
I have Bluepoint, which is Snapon's lower line, but still carry the same warantee. Also a bit less than Snapon, but more expensive and I feel higher quality than Craftsman. The one exception I made is the ratchet, which I also bought a Snapon because of the fine teeth and is wonderful for tight places. I don't wrench for a living, but don't want to tear up my hands when something breaks or strip out anything. That being said, I do have an older set of Cobalt deep 1/2 drive sockets, which seem to do fine.
 
   / Best wrench brand I can afford? #28  
Watch craigslist swap meets or garage sales. I hate chinese HF tools. You can find sets from mechanics getting out of the business or what not. Some get hard up for cash and unload tools. I bought this less than year old snap on box for a $1K, threw in another hundred and got some pullers and compression test kit. Guy that lives behind me buys used/broken snap on for little to nothing and trades it on new. I wish I had the money back from cheap tools I wasted. You don't have to buy premium tools at premium prices.
 

Attachments

  • image-24580112.jpg
    image-24580112.jpg
    377 KB · Views: 109
   / Best wrench brand I can afford? #29  
I have mostly craftsman. The Sears is close and still does not give me a hassle when I bring something back. If I break something that I use a lot more than twice I will upgrade that item to snap-on. I would break a lot of 10mm 6pt craftsman sockets wrenching on imports when I worked at the garage. Once I switched that socket to snap-on I never broke another.

For smaller sizes I prefer better quality. Craftsman or Husky versus Harbor Freight. Better tolerances means it is less likely to strip the nut. For larger sizes I don't use often HF is OK. At sizes larger than 3/4 tolerance and strength is not as critical.

My favorite ratchet though is still a long handled snap-on. Much better that craftsman. The ratchet requires less of an arc to engage which is great for tighter spaces. I also have a swivel head which has more gear teeth than the pear head design which means shorter movement before next tooth is engaged. Great for tight spaces.

I am a firm believer of the adage "Buy quality tools, take care of them , and they will last a lifetime."
 
   / Best wrench brand I can afford? #30  
Just like the op. I have a collection of all sorts of brands. But the only brand I will not use is Buffalo. I hope they are not in business anymore. Their open-end wrenches would spread apart VERY easily. Now i buy what the nearest store to me sells and i don't give a rats-patootie about a life-time warranty.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2015 Peterbilt 320 T/A EZ-Pack Front Loader Garbage Truck (A51692)
2015 Peterbilt 320...
2000 New Holland TN65 Tractor with Loader (A51573)
2000 New Holland...
2014 FORREST RIVER SALEM TRAVEL TRAILER (A52472)
2014 FORREST RIVER...
2007 Ford Ranger Pickup Truck (A50323)
2007 Ford Ranger...
2005 KENWORTH T800 (A52472)
2005 KENWORTH T800...
JOHN DEERE 5125R LOT NUMBER 24 (A53084)
JOHN DEERE 5125R...
 
Top