I have a Simplicity Legacy. 27HP diesel with turf tires. I bought a 4ft box blade and used it to clean out about 1/4 acre of thick woods. I also removed most of my lawn and then spread 9 tandems of topsoil. Between the FEL and the box blade, it worked fine. Box weighs around 350 lbs. without any add-ons.
There is no question that you can bog down though. The depth of the shanks and the angle of the blade makes all the difference. Personally I would go for the smaller box, if this is the type of work you're looking at. It won't take much bogging down to get you frustrated. It also becomes more work to smooth out the pile you've made.