Catfish have to be the toughest creatures..

   / Catfish have to be the toughest creatures.. #1  

sendero

Gold Member
Joined
Apr 9, 2003
Messages
318
Location
Grayson County TX
Tractor
Kioti DK35
... on the planet! Ok, this anecdote is going to reveal what a total city-boy I am. Sure, I've fished and I can catch fish and besides, anyone could catch a fish from my pond.

But last week I decided it was time to eat one of the catfish I stocked my pond with almost 2 years ago. These fish are running just under 2 lbs from my eyeball estimation (I get a good look at them when I throw that catfish food on the water and they come up to get it /forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif ).

However, they were apparently not as hungry as the 4 pounder who wound up on my line. Ok, more fish to eat, no problem.

Now, I've never cleaned a fish in my life but I can read and I've looked at 2-3 sets of instructions for doing so. I decided this fish wasn't quite big enough to "steak" and was too big to "cook whole", so I went for the filet. I dragged him over to a work area and got my filet knife, a hammer, filet glove and skinning pliers.

Now, the crusty old devil wasn't dead and none of the cleaning instructions I had addressed the issue of finishing him off before the slicing was to commence. So, I whacked him with a hammer, square on the head. This really didn't seem to bother him that much.

So I whacked him again. And again, harder and harder. Frankly, the fish did not seem to really care. He still flopped occassionally and the gills maintained their rhythmic movement.

I called my brother who fishes a lot and hangs with an Arkansas boy who is a "pro". He said I should cut his head off. Well, that sounded like a good enough idea, so I got a hatchet. I whacked the fish at the back of the head, hard - and again, other than starting to bleed a bit it really didn't bother the fish. I was really wanting to get this baby cleaned, fileted and on ice - but I decided that time would probably be the best killer. I wandered off to the shed to put some stuff away.

I came back 15 minutes later and the fish was still breathing. At this point I was getting annoyed. I just wanted the darn fish to have a happy death so I could eat him. He was making me feel real guilty just by continuing to breathe after all the abuse I'd heaped on him.

So, I took the .22 mag revolver I carry around (varmints) out of my pocket and shot him right "between the eyes". I suddenly heard my wife laughing from the trailer - she witnessed the execution. I went inside and she was laughing so hard she had tears in her eyes. She said "well you killed him didn't you! The way you stood back after you shot him, you looked like you expected him to fight back!" And you know what? If that **** fish had flopped back to the pond after I shot it, it would not have surprised me /forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif

Ok, all you experienced fishermen, how the **** are you supposed to kill these **** things. And please don't suggest that I just clean him alive, that isn't gonna happen /forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif (And BTW, I realize that "cleaning" isn't strictly necessary to filet, but I still wanted him dead before I started skinning.)
 
   / Catfish have to be the toughest creatures.. #2  
Your wife wasn’t the only one that laughed until she cried. I did too. That was great. It was all that I could do to finish reading the post.
 
   / Catfish have to be the toughest creatures.. #3  
Well, this reply is coming from probably the least qualified person on TBN as I haven't dressed a fish in years. But, I recall that you get a piece of lumber and drive a 16d nail through the head (fish's, not yours) and into the board. This accomplishes 2 things. One, it kills the catfish (maybe) and two, it secures the fish so you can skin it. Even if the nail does not "Kill" the fish, it probably renders it brain dead so that even if there are other signs of life, you are not really torturing the fish while you "skin it alive".

Now, for all you real fishermen out there, is my memory in tact or was this answer way off base?
 
   / Catfish have to be the toughest creatures.. #4  
Your wife needed a camera, I can just see the clip on Americas Funniest Home Videos.

But I'm not sure why the fish was alive after you hit it in the head. That all I ever do, one good smack with a small bat and it's all over.

Now I have seen a 80lb halibut next to the boat and there was no messing around, 38 to the head and finish death throws before it comes aboard...I guess they can really tear up a boat in a hurry.
 
   / Catfish have to be the toughest creatures.. #5  
I think you need to sharpen that hatchet! /forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif /forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif

We had more bullheads than catfish, but I recall they clean the same.

Both for fear of torturing the critter and getting stung by it, I always opted to cut the head off (butcher or hunting knife), before skinning. However, I've seen it done much faster skinning it alive, then slicing the head almost off: a quick tug takes it and the guts at the same time.
 
   / Catfish have to be the toughest creatures.. #6  
Catfish might be tough to kill but I sure love to take a filet with some bacon around it wrapped up in foil and toss it on the grill! /forums/images/graemlins/wink.gif
 
   / Catfish have to be the toughest creatures.. #7  
As far as killing a fish before you clean it I agree that a catfish is much harder to deal with. In fishing, catching, and throwing the caught fish on shore until it was time to head for home it's been my experience that Trout seem to live the longest out of water though. Not even sure why that is..... Maybe we should call MythBusters.
 
   / Catfish have to be the toughest creatures.. #8  
Not sure on the trout lasting longer as I never caught a wild one, but some of the big cats can last hours on shore with still being alive. we had a stringer full of cats once and had em in the edge of the pond, when a snapper ? ate the lowr half of all of em left the heads still gasping /forums/images/graemlins/blush.gif the Nail through the head into a board works well. for cleaning as well as finishing em off. the brain is slightly behind the eyes though.

I aint cleaned one in years either /forums/images/graemlins/frown.gif mostly cause of not enough time for fishing anymore /forums/images/graemlins/frown.gif /forums/images/graemlins/frown.gif

nothing beter than a pan full of blue gils though /forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif

mark M
 
   / Catfish have to be the toughest creatures..
  • Thread Starter
#9  
Well, for what it's worth, "Fred" (as my wife named him, I don't know why) was mighty good eatin'. Much better than that store catfish-farm fish - deep fried with a cornmeal coat, he was tender, flaky and tasty and pleasantly asbsent of worms.

My pond also has a boatload of bluegill. When I was a kiddo, we once lived near the intersection of 2 freeways and there was a creek behind our house. I pulled 35 "sunfish" out of that creek (ok, my brother helped) and mom cleaned them and fried them up and I'm telling you that might have been the best fish dinner I ever had, and that was 40 years ago /forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif

The board with nail trick sounds like it is probably a good solution. Although to be honest, .22. mag shells are only about 15 cents each, and they sure solved the problem /forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif /forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif
 
   / Catfish have to be the toughest creatures.. #10  
Funny story!
At a young age, my Dad taught me the best way to clean a catfish. He vice-gripped the tail to the big cutting board, picnic table, or whatever he was cutting on, leaned on the fish's body, then cut off the head. Seemed cruel to me, but it always works.

Steve
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2010 Ford Edge SE SUV (A51694)
2010 Ford Edge SE...
Kubota BX2230D (A47384)
Kubota BX2230D...
RoGator RG1100C (A55302)
RoGator RG1100C...
2025 JMR 40in Single Cylinder Grapple Skid Steer Attachment (A53421)
2025 JMR 40in...
2015 Ford Escape SUV (A50324)
2015 Ford Escape...
2025 Swict 72in Bucket Skid Steer Attachment (A53421)
2025 Swict 72in...
 
Top