Comparo of 4x20 and 5x25...images dialups beware

   / Comparo of 4x20 and 5x25...images dialups beware #1  

fastpat

Silver Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2005
Messages
206
Location
Travelers Rest, South Carolina
A comparison, first is me on a 4320 and then D.'s 4720 and 5525.

4320_me_3-vi.jpg


746649jd5525vs4720sideshot-vi.jpg


Added: 4720 with cab:
4720_cab-vi.jpg


Man, D., that 5525 is a rather healthy tractor, and that HX-15 is one big mower. /forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif
 
   / Comparo of 4x20 and 5x25...images dialups beware #2  
What do you plan on doing with this tractor? You need to look at the pro and cons of the two lines - there are plenty.

D.
 
   / Comparo of 4x20 and 5x25...images dialups beware #3  
Nice photos. I especially like the face to face greeting. Looks like they should bow to each other.

Cliff
 
   / Comparo of 4x20 and 5x25...images dialups beware #4  
Here is a list to start off with in regards to the pros and cons:

4720:
PRO:
Plenty of power
HST trans
All kinds of accessories, but the 5525 has that also.
4WD standard
Cruise
Nimble (good turning radius)

CONS:
Can't pull a bat-wing style mower.
Can't handle larger implements like balers, etc.
Electronic PTO - I am not totally sold on it - I like being able to feather in the PTO

5525
PROS:
Larger & Heavier Unit - will pull anything I need.
EPTO - way cool for smaller PTO implements
Cab Available (It rocks)
e-hitch is pretty slick
4WD mode can be in auto, which is very slick
Will fit on a standard low boy trailer (6000 series are too wide) I wish my HX15 would fit - oh well, I dont plan on taking it anywhere else.

CONS:
Not Cheap - I paid $41K
No HST, but the power reverser works well
Turning radius sucks, I have learned that with my HX15 behind me, leave plenty of room for turning.

I ended up with both due to different reasons. Probably the most convincing reason was the addition of another 160 acres to our 20. On 20 acres, it is hard to justify the 5525 when I already have the 4720. I plan on keeping both, they each play a different role around our place.

I see the tractor you took a pic on has turf tires. Unless I am working on a golf course, I would go with R4s. My 4720 with R4s does not tear up my yard. I had a 2210 with turfs and it got stuck sometimes (I think due to the lack of weight).

Both tractors rock. Now that I have a cab, I am not sure how I lived without one. I think I take longer to get jobs done now that I have it! A cab sure is easier on my allergies.

I am sure I will come up with mroe pros and cons. If I could have ordered my tractors again after now used them awhile, I would change the accessory orders up some for sure.

D.
 
   / Comparo of 4x20 and 5x25...images dialups beware #5  
Here is another pic that compares the rears of the 4720 with MX6 and the 5525 with HX15. I ran the MX6 on the 5525 for a week or so. It is nice to be able to move my implements from tractor to tractor. the 5525 with the MX6 will fit on my trailer in case I want to go elsewhere and mow in comfort.

D.
 

Attachments

  • 746854-jd4720vs5525rear640.jpg
    746854-jd4720vs5525rear640.jpg
    72.8 KB · Views: 333
   / Comparo of 4x20 and 5x25...images dialups beware
  • Thread Starter
#6  
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( What do you plan on doing with this tractor? You need to look at the pro and cons of the two lines - there are plenty.

D.)</font>

The 4320 in the photo was the only 4x20 series the dealer had in stock, already sold to a government school in Monterey county to mow their lawns, and not much else, hence the Turf tires.

I've just about come to the conclusion that a 4720 will meet my needs just about 95% of the time on my hillside hobby farm. If I need something larger, I can rent, an excavator for example.

Since I'll only need a backhoe on occaision, a 4720 with cab makes sense, particularly when the humidity and temperature are at their peak in summer.

Then, again, leaving off the cab will go a long way towards funding a backhoe.

As for the 5x25 series, they're certainly capable tractors, with the capacity to do far more than I'd ever ask of them while owning 11 acres. That's the rub, I just don't need that kind of power, not to mention expense of initial purchase AND operating cost.

That's where I am today, 4720 w/backhoe or 4720 w/cab and everything else but a backhoe. This isn't easy, at least looking is relatively low cost. /forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif
 
   / Comparo of 4x20 and 5x25...images dialups beware #7  
The backhoe part is tough. They are handy, but I am having a hard time talking myself into one. Also, if i had to make the choice between a 4720 with a cab and a 4720 with MAYBE a backhoe - that is a no brainer - cab all the way. I am so sold on the cabs. If I had to, I could live with just my 5525 with a front end loader on it and ditch the 4720. Then again, they are both so handy in their own way.

What other options are you thinking about on the 4720?

I have i-match on mine, and I would consider doing the adjustable draft links and bypassing the whole i-match thing.

I would add automotive cruise.

Clear filter bowl.

FEL?

MX6?

400X or 400CX?

What else is there to add?

D.
 
   / Comparo of 4x20 and 5x25...images dialups beware
  • Thread Starter
#8  
   / Comparo of 4x20 and 5x25...images dialups beware #9  
DD, What options would you change on the 5525?

You were talking about the electronic PTO on the 4720. Depending on the transmission I think you could end up with it on the 5525 also.
 
   / Comparo of 4x20 and 5x25...images dialups beware #10  
Good call on not buying a Chinese wood chipper. I wish I had bought a bearcat. I have worked on my chipper more than I have used it.

On the boxblade width, I bought one that is just the width of the tractor. that way I can take it on a trailer easier.

Are you going to add top n tilt?

You might want a disc harrow to help bust things up. I went with a Frontier DH1176.

Are you going to mow your lawn? You might want a RFM or a MMM.

It sounds like you are narrowing your order down quickly.

D.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2011 FREIGHTLINER M2 TANDEM AXLE FLATBED TRUCK (A51222)
2011 FREIGHTLINER...
2006 International 9400i (A51039)
2006 International...
2023 MAXXD TDX Drop-N-Load Trailer with Air Ride Suspension and Tilt Deck (A51039)
2023 MAXXD TDX...
Brent 420 Grain Cart (A50514)
Brent 420 Grain...
2025 Swict 84in Bucket Skid Steer Attachment (A50322)
2025 Swict 84in...
2018 Toro Grounds Master 7200 72in Zero Turn Commercial Mower (A50324)
2018 Toro Grounds...
 
Top