Ray,
I've heard mention of losing HP when converting to propane and I'm not nearly an expert enough to say one way or the other. I'd recommend upgrading to a larger generator if you're already near your maximum draw.
Obviously that is an option, but not one I will ever consider. I have almost nothing to gain.
I have a high end 5500 watt generator that I only use once or twice a year, for a few hours. It runs a list of things so long, no one believes me, when it list them all. The only thing I turn off for it, is my central air.
It would make no sense for me to spend a wad of money, (I don't have), to replace it with a big expensive one that can run on propane, in the off chance there will be another event that will require me to run it for more than a day or two continuously, (which is about how much gasoline I keep on hand), and be in a situation where I would not be able to buy, or acquire, any gasoline anywhere.
Even if that happens, I have a propane fireplace for emergency heat, and I never have a large amount of food that would be lost to a power failure. So, it would be far cheaper to take the hit.
If I thought I could spare the HP, and I don't, I would spend the money to convert mine to propane, so I wouldn't need to keep so much gasoline around. But that's as far as I will go.