ericm979
Super Member
- Joined
- Nov 25, 2016
- Messages
- 5,810
- Location
- Santa Cruz Mountains CA, Southern OR
- Tractor
- Branson 3725H Deere 5105
I have read several predation studies and the overall scientific take away is they just aren't sure, less coyotes, more fawns survive and than starve due to overfeeding. Historically anytime man has tried to manage nature it has turned into a gaggle.
Personally I have not seen the deer herds significantly impacted either way by the local coyote population.
Coyotes aren't going to take a lot of deer. They can take fawns but adult or even half grown deer are too big. I've seen does chasing coyotes.
Predator/prey population dynamics are well understood. We've seen crashes in prey populations due to killing predators over and over (because humans are dumb and keep trying the same thing). Yellowstone in the early 1900s is a classic example. They killed off the wolves and the elk populations exploded and then crashed as many starved. Same on the Kaibab plateau and many others.
I like seeing animals of all kinds. I don't kill them, not even rattlesnakes. But we no longer have outdoor pets. We had one outdoor cat who grew up in the area and was very tough. The only cat I've seen with bulging muscles. Even she got grabbed by something though she managed to make it home and survive. We retired her to indoor duty and she lived to 17.
If I moved to where we are now (which has a lot of predators) with a small dog I'd either keep it in or build a predator proof run. It'd likely get eaten otherwise. Shooting the coyotes won't help much as it's the coyote that you don't see that will take it.