Well, Yaouk, Debate away, as soon as I can direct you to the person, persons, or agency responsible for the othe rside of the argument. I promise you it isn't me. I came apon this "information" from a contractor putting in the septic system for my mom's new house. He was talking about the use of the ground up tires being encouraged/allowed by the state DEQ (Department of Environmental Quality) but outlawing privately held caches of used tires above 50 in number (I'm pretty sure about the number = 50 but it was a year ago). I commented on the seeming contradictory stand (not unusual for governing bodies).
I had been telling this gentleman how I had some ideas/plans for using used tires in columns and or in interlocking courses in conjunction with concrete for building a dam and some retaining walls. That is when he explained how the law prevented that use (> 50). This man is one of a very few folks in the state that hold a current lisc as waste disposal-landfill operator. He does not currently operate a facilitly but is lisc to do so and is current in training and understanding regulaltions.
I also mentioned rammed earth ala the "Earth Ship" approach in New Mexico and how that would be illegal in light of his information. The rammed earth inside tires as apposed to other forms etc, I think was pioneered by the Earth Ship folks. This is the butt ugly thingy to which you refer, yes? The esthetes among rammed earth practitioners cover over, plaster, stucco, or otherwise hide the tires as most straw bale builders obscure the direct view of the straw in their construction projects.
Sorry to "wimp out" on you debate wise but I have no desire to take up a view contrary to yours just because someone told me information that is contrary to your belief. Regarding your faith regarding the rectitude of all things government approved... TSK TSK TSK, the gulibility of youth... Irrespective of how rampant your eco-concern and confidence in "RIGHT BY ASSOCIATION with Government actions or decisions", I'd like to hear credible facts whether or not tires are a significant source of poutants, petro-chemicals, or ... I'm not claiming anything resembling papal infalibility. Maybe someone out there could enlighten us regarding the decomposition products of tires and their bio-effects in the ecosystem.
Patrick