I'm doing the work. No roofers involved. These were all large, long term companies- two lumberyards and one supplier to contractors. Due to the differences, I now have to go visit each one of them in person to find out why they quoted how they did. Plus, I now have to check a fourth company a bit father away that rolls their own metal roofing to customer order to see what their current pricing is.
Quotes are running close to $2.50 per linear foot for standard 5 rib metal. Not too long ago, I was paying more like $1.80 or so.
And why would the same piece, a W valley 10'6" long run $23.25, $21.48 and $34.70? The first two are close to what I expected, so why is the third so much higher?