For building small sheds - What are good siding materials compared to Hardie Panels?

   / For building small sheds - What are good siding materials compared to Hardie Panels? #1  

newbury

Super Star Member
Joined
Jan 8, 2009
Messages
13,983
Location
From Vt, in Va, retiring to MS
Tractor
Kubota's - B7610, M4700
I'm going to be building several SMALL sheds (6x10 or smaller) for garden tools, fencing, etc. at several different sites. I've used Hardie Panel and liked it, but the cost seems to have greatly escalated, as have all things.
My main consideration is LOW MAINTENANCE, the 10x15 Hardie Panel shed I built ~25 years ago was painted well (edges and 2 coats) when I built it and has required no maintenance (other than blowing leaves out) since.
So I'm looking at LP Smartside, but read it needs to be repainted, one web source says every two to three years, others 5 to 10 years. For me 2 years would be a pain in the butt, 5 years, not so bad, 10 years great. But compared to Hardie Panel which seems once and done any repainting should not be needed.
Smartside would be lighter, but I'm not building ice shanties.
If I could find vinyl siding in 4x8 sheets that might be a contender, but the widest vinyl siding I've found is ~ 9" (Ply Gem - Transformations Double 5 in. x 144 in. White Lap Vinyl Siding at HD), And I figure I'd need horizontal nailing strips every 9". The Hardie Panels were fine with the vertical studs ~ every 2'.
So TBN - is there anything else out there before I sink my $$ into Hardie panels?
 
   / For building small sheds - What are good siding materials compared to Hardie Panels? #3  
I don't know anything about Hardie panels but I do know about Hardie Plank siding and problems with LP cement siding. I chose Hardie Plank siding for my house 18 years ago because of the excellent reviews and because LP siding problems and recalls. Present day and my siding is in like new condition. Only had to paint once so far. I live in the PNW so rain and moisture can be big problems. So maybe just stick with you have so far. I also had Hardie Board installed in the bathrooms instead of green board. No problems so far. I think Hardie really did a great job with their cement board products. Maybe I should invest in the company. I know, I sound like an ad, but I have no interest of any kind in the company, just a really happy customer.
Eric
 
   / For building small sheds - What are good siding materials compared to Hardie Panels? #4  
Sheet it with OSB, then tar paper, then colored steel roofing panels or siding panels.
 
   / For building small sheds - What are good siding materials compared to Hardie Panels? #5  
I'm going to be building several SMALL sheds (6x10 or smaller) for garden tools, fencing, etc. at several different sites. I've used Hardie Panel and liked it, but the cost seems to have greatly escalated, as have all things.
My main consideration is LOW MAINTENANCE, the 10x15 Hardie Panel shed I built ~25 years ago was painted well (edges and 2 coats) when I built it and has required no maintenance (other than blowing leaves out) since.
So I'm looking at LP Smartside, but read it needs to be repainted, one web source says every two to three years, others 5 to 10 years. For me 2 years would be a pain in the butt, 5 years, not so bad, 10 years great. But compared to Hardie Panel which seems once and done any repainting should not be needed.
Smartside would be lighter, but I'm not building ice shanties.
If I could find vinyl siding in 4x8 sheets that might be a contender, but the widest vinyl siding I've found is ~ 9" (Ply Gem - Transformations Double 5 in. x 144 in. White Lap Vinyl Siding at HD), And I figure I'd need horizontal nailing strips every 9". The Hardie Panels were fine with the vertical studs ~ every 2'.
So TBN - is there anything else out there before I sink my $$ into Hardie panels?
If you were going for 8x20 sized sheds, then one of the cost effective ways and still have steel walls is a short sea container.

They do have 8x10, but rare in many areas. These are $1,000 to $1,200. When you build your own, the materials and time cost you much more.
1734315040635.png


The 8x20 are the most popular. Priced $1,800 to $2,200
1734315206424.png


These come in all kinds of colors too. Will last well over 50 years.
Plus, the 10 and 20 foot longs can be easily flat trucked to most locations vs a semi with a flat trailer.
So the shipping is way less. Most places offer free shipping in 25 or 50 mile radius too. So shop around.

Compared to a regular shed, it's harder to break into these containers to steal things. Most thief's do not carry a cutting torch with them.

Here is a nice 20 footer,

future - 20x8x9 sea container.jpg


1734315912360.png
 
Last edited:
   / For building small sheds - What are good siding materials compared to Hardie Panels? #6  
   / For building small sheds - What are good siding materials compared to Hardie Panels? #7  
If he's retired now in MS, the thin sheds will blow away like dust in the 1st hurricane. The reason why I suggested the shipping container.
 
   / For building small sheds - What are good siding materials compared to Hardie Panels? #8  
If he's retired now in MS, the thin sheds will blow away like dust in the 1st hurricane. The reason why I suggested the shipping container.
Yeah, those sheds are like a square tin can. They start falling apart if you raise your voice too much around them.
 
   / For building small sheds - What are good siding materials compared to Hardie Panels?
  • Thread Starter
#9  
If he's retired now in MS, the thin sheds will blow away like dust in the 1st hurricane. The reason why I suggested the shipping container.
I've been retired since ~2010 and life has seriously gotten in the way of moving to Mississippi :(
And SWMBO had said no metal sheds. I was hoping some other manufacturer had come out with a Hardie type material or large vinyl UV resistant sheet material that I didn't know about.
 
   / For building small sheds - What are good siding materials compared to Hardie Panels? #10  
I've been retired since ~2010 and life has seriously gotten in the way of moving to Mississippi :(
And SWMBO had said no metal sheds. I was hoping some other manufacturer had come out with a Hardie type material or large vinyl UV resistant sheet material that I didn't know about.
It leaves you to the most primitive structure then, cinder blocks.

1734329602321.jpeg



Then using masonry paint . . .

1734329753114.jpeg
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2022 Bobcat E60 Excavator (A42203)
2022 Bobcat E60...
JCB 950 MAST FORKLIFT (A45046)
JCB 950 MAST...
AGT MX15RX Mini Excavator (A44501)
AGT MX15RX Mini...
AGCO Sunflower Disc Harrow (A44501)
AGCO Sunflower...
2025 Swict 84in Bucket Skid Steer Attachment (A44571)
2025 Swict 84in...
Case-IH 140 Maxxum (A44501)
Case-IH 140 Maxxum...
 
Top