ptsg
Super Member
Good and fair question. Speaking from personal experience, I could not find a new domestic built bulldozer in the size I wanted with the features I needed so there was no real choices to be made. I currently have over 700 hours on it and it's still going strong. Yes, there are some shortcomings such as lack of track frame covers and a belly pan, and poorly designed rock guards, and they are not very heavy for the power they have - not deal breakers if you operate the machine accordingly. Admittedly, they are poor candidates for notch dozing. I have made many modifications such as adding laser operated machine control, winches, etc. It also has a front end loader attachment. So you ask is it just as reliable? I would have to answer yes, even though there is nothing to compare it to. Any ground engaging equipment is going to wear and break, and requires diligent maintenance.
If you perused the list of tractors in my previous post you'll see that some of your "major brands" are in fact made in China and other countries. Any more, "Made in America" in a lot of cases just means "Assembled in America". There is also the demographic factor - how many Rhodes Scholars do you know of that operate tractors regularly?
And by "Assembled in America", most of the times is just mounting the wheels and ROPS in place.