I can't buy the "virtually no training, general direction thing"
Okay, so maybe I overstated the case. Let me be a little more accurate: Cock it. Point it at the door through which the intruder is coming. Pull trigger.
And not to brag on Dad, but his real world experience was extensive. He was ATF back when most people around here and in Mississippi called him a 'revenuer'. They would spend days staking out stills, miles from nowhere, wait until dark and rush the still. Just him and his partner. Day after day, week after week. He described that aspect of his job as fun. Most of the confrontations involved fists, wrestling and a lot of running...rarely any shooting. When moonshine dried up it was mostly gun and explosive enforcement. He
hated that. He consider moonshiners to at least be rational people that he often liked and respected. The illegal gun trafficers and bomb nuts where a whole other breed of crazy. It was dealing with those crazies that both of his partners were shot (one in Mississippi, one in Florida, neither killed but one injured very badly...and again, he was stationed elsewhere.) He only carried a pistol because they made him and it was a snub nosed .38. At any other time he had a shotgun in his hand.
But when I envision myself in a bad situation (which are better avoided in virtually every circumstance....i.e., wisdom is more powerful than a gun), if I am honest with myself, I can see me messing things up with a pistol, possibly hurting myself with it and in the better circumstance not even hitting what I'm shooting at. It happens ALL THE TIME, even with trained law enforcement. I see myself much more likely to be able to cock-point-pull trigger of a small shotgun when I'm in one of those pee in your pants situations. Others will see it differently and I'm not knocking pistols for self defense. You can't really tote a shotgun everywhere you can tote a pistol. And maybe each person has to know himself when choosing a weapon and maybe I just don't see myself as being competent with dealing with the intricacies of a pistol when things go south.
Anyway, I'm going to spend some time with the 1911. It is fun to shoot. And once I get used to it, it will probably be a perfectly serviceable self defense weapon to stick in the truck when I'm heading down to my cabin.