Grapple on a 2310

2310 guy · Apr 30, 2007

DanielAlexander said:
Hi Danny, Jeff at Anbo sent prices, 38" $2,420, 48" $2,375 with 6" spacing without hoses and mounts.I like the upper tine frame length, and close capability to 3", it's more like a rake to gather stuff.Can you get Millonzi prices,. I also like W.R.Long electric joy stick switch, for the third function.

$$$$ wow. That to rich for my blood. Looks like I might be making a grapple before buying one. What do you guys think the tines should be made out of? 1/4" or 3/8" steel? I would like to use 1/4" because its light and cheaper than 3/8". The problem is 1/4 might be to weak, even for the little 2310.

What do you 2310 guys think?

DannyLobster · Apr 30, 2007

2310 guy said:
$$$$ wow. That to rich for my blood. Looks like I might be making a grapple before buying one. What do you guys think the tines should be made out of? 1/4" or 3/8" steel? I would like to use 1/4" because its light and cheaper than 3/8". The problem is 1/4 might be to weak, even for the little 2310.

What do you 2310 guys think?

A bit rich for me too. I will let you know when I get a quote form Millonzi. I have seen $695 quoted a couple of times. nor sure what that includes or what else is needed.

Dan

IslandTractor · May 1, 2007

Sorry guys, I posted the wrong TBN user name for Joe Millonzi yesterday. It should be Joe@mi

Or, you can look at their website at Millonzi International Homepage

Again, I am not certain but I do think that Joe has access to better pricing for TBN folks than the regular sales staff.

IslandTractor · May 1, 2007

2310 guy said:
What do you guys think the tines should be made out of? 1/4" or 3/8" steel? I would like to use 1/4" because its light and cheaper than 3/8". The problem is 1/4 might be to weak, even for the little 2310.

What do you 2310 guys think?

I have the Millonzi LD48 and it has 3/8 inch steel "fangs" top and bottom (I forget the technical term right now). I don't think you'll find any grapples made with 1/4 inch mild steel. The LD48 weighs 285lbs which is only about 100-150lbs more than your basic bucket so it should leave you with a good amount of lift capacity.

2310 guy · May 1, 2007

IslandTractor said:
I have the Millonzi LD48 and it has 3/8 inch steel "fangs" top and bottom (I forget the technical term right now). I don't think you'll find any grapples made with 1/4 inch mild steel. The LD48 weighs 285lbs which is only about 100-150lbs more than your basic bucket so it should leave you with a good amount of lift capacity.

Yeah, I kinda thought 1/4" would be to thin. This is probably a better grapple for my needs. I would make something like this out of 3/8". It shouldn't take to much lifting capacity away from the FEL either. The hardest part will be to find time between all my other projects.

DannyLobster · May 1, 2007

2310 guy said:
Yeah, I kinda thought 1/4" would be to thin. This is probably a better grapple for my needs. I would make something like this out of 3/8". It shouldn't take to much lifting capacity away from the FEL either. The hardest part will be to find time between all my other projects.

Hey 2310Guy
Where is the bolt on grapple from?
Dan

IslandTractor · May 1, 2007

DannyLobster said:
Where is the bolt on grapple from?

It has a round tube so I think it is an ATI. Wikco makes essentially the same thing with a square tube. Nice design and pretty easy to install with only a few bolt holes to drill in either case. I recall the ATI is a bit more money.

Bucket grapples are definitely a major improvement over a plain bucket or bucket with just a toothbar and chain hooks. Night and day. However, a full grapple goes even further and does not cost much more. As I recall the ATI will set you back about $600, the Wikco about $500. That is not so far off from what the Millonzi LD48 costs (about $700).

There is one major advantage to the bucket grapples which is that it is always on the bucket (it can be taken off but there is not much reason to do so as the grapple would rarely interfer with regular bucket work) and also that unlike with a true full grapple, you still have the use of your bucket.

2310 guy · May 1, 2007

DannyLobster said:
Hey 2310Guy
Where is the bolt on grapple from?
Dan

Here you go.
Google Image Result for http://www.preseeder.com/attachments/GK-4866.jpg

I would make it with a sqaure tube opposed to the round one. The only part I haven't fugure out would be where to mount the control. Maybe foot control on the left side.

DannyLobster · May 2, 2007

IslandTractor said:
There is one major advantage to the bucket grapples which is that it is always on the bucket (it can be taken off but there is not much reason to do so as the grapple would rarely interfer with regular bucket work) and also that unlike with a true full grapple, you still have the use of your bucket.

The Millonzi looks like it is a bit deeper. Is that an illusion or how deep is it from the back wall to the fang tip??
Plus it does not have the sides getting in the way allowing me to pick up longer stuff easier.

I have not yet taken the bucket off, but it does not look too bad.

I got a note back and need to complete a spec of my loader hitch.

Dan

IslandTractor · May 2, 2007

DannyLobster said:
The Millonzi looks like it is a bit deeper. Is that an illusion or how deep is it from the back wall to the fang tip??
Plus it does not have the sides getting in the way allowing me to pick up longer stuff easier.

Don't take my positive comments on the bucket grapple as an indication that there are no advantages to the real grapple. Bucket grapples are compromises while real grapples are dedicated tools and therefore have some serious advantages. The real grapples are far more effective at grappling material for some of the reasons you indicated. The bucket sides do not interfer and they generally have a greater capacity per bite. You can also dig with them to rip up roots (hence the term root grapple) which would be done but much less efficiently with a bucket/toothbar combo. Bottom line is that the main advantage of a bucket grapple, like a Swiss Army knife, is that it is convenient and cheaper than a series of dedicated tools. The real grapple is going to out perform the bucket grapple in brush removal every time.

I'd personally like one of each

. A dedicated grapple when I know I am clearing brush or moving stumps etc and a grapple bucket for general purpose bucket work where being able to grapple something rather than get off the tractor to chain it would be a great convenience.