Help sizing and choosing a tractor, JD vs. Kubota

   / Help sizing and choosing a tractor, JD vs. Kubota #11  
</font><font color="blue" class="small">( you often step on one brake pedal with the steering wheel turned, excellerate, and spin the tractor on a dime )</font>

With the B7800's pedals this can be done with toe on the brake pedal and heel on the speed control pedal.
 
   / Help sizing and choosing a tractor, JD vs. Kubota
  • Thread Starter
#12  
Well, I spent a few weeks looking and contemplating, and I think I'm going to get the JD 3720 (which replaces the 4410) if the dealers price seems right. I decided on the extra power of the 3720 over (say) the 3120 because it adds 20% to my spending for a nearly 50% increase in power, and some of the attachments I'm considering recomend a minimum 30HP at the PTO which only the 3520 and 3720 have.

I have a few remaining questions I hope the group can help with ...

1. I'm getting the 61" bucket on the FEL which can take a replacable cutting edge ($100) - buying the heavy duty bucket is only $100 more, so there doesn't seem a reason not to, unless it is a complete waste - any opinions on whether the regular bucket is adequate, especially given I plan to use the replacable edges?

2. I'm debating whether to get the 72" mower deck - for about the same price I can buy a separate L120 garden tractor which will be dedicated to grass cutting - I only get a 48" deck on the L120 instead of 72" on the 3720, but the mower will be much lighter (less compaction) and I won't ever have to take it on/off - for a bit more money I might buy a zero turn type mower instead, and have both a bigger deck and lighter weight, so that is another option. Opinions?

3. I'm considering a 44 bushel Trac-Vac to pick up grass and (especially) leaves, but I've heard from one landscapper that they can clog a lot and are not worth it - one friend recomended I buy a $250 Lawn Sweeper instead, which won't re-mulch it but will pick up debris - any opinions on how lawn vacuems work and the best way to deal with large amounts of leaves and grass?

4. Lastly, I think I may get the turf tires and then add chains for traction when I need them, instead of R4's - I'm thinking this gives me the best of both without having to swap tires - opinions?

Many many thanks - you all have been /forums/images/graemlins/cool.gif
 
   / Help sizing and choosing a tractor, JD vs. Kubota #13  
As far as the bucket goes, I guess that depends on what you'll be doing with it. If you think you'll end up banging it around a lot and possibly bending the lighter bucket, I'd opt for the heavy bucket (which is what we have).

We have the R4 tires and I don't think I'd go with anything less aggressive than those for our situation (hills/inclines). Personally, I'm a little lazy when it comes to adding things to temporarily improve something and then removing it again when not needed. I just can't see myself out there fooling with chains. I know I'd be cursing and wondering why the heck I didn't just get better tires in the first place. But that's just me /forums/images/graemlins/wink.gif If you think you might find yourself in that situation later, get the R4's.

Good luck. The 3720 looks like lots of fun /forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif
 
   / Help sizing and choosing a tractor, JD vs. Kubota #14  
If you are buying a dedicated mower, get the R4's. There are many times I wish I had R1's. Do you have any soft areas of mud on your property? This tractor is not that heavy and if you wait til your lawn dries, R4's shouldn't be a problem. Unless you are a lawn perfectionist.
 
   / Help sizing and choosing a tractor, JD vs. Kubota #15  
Back to your backhoe debate for a moment, Homeboy. I am a recent purchaser of a JD 4410 with a 48 backhoe. I simply love it. The ease of installation and removal is nothing short of amazing. I can't imagine that they went backwards with 448.

One thing I would consider in your shoes is to look at a 4410 if you can still find one. I sat on and drove both the 3520 and 4410 and felt more comfortable with the 4410 --- it was also quite a bit less expensive since it has been replaced.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2019 Peterbilt 520 Front Load Garbage Truck (A45336)
2019 Peterbilt 520...
2025 Dig Master DM100 UNUSED Mini Excavator (A47484)
2025 Dig Master...
2010 Toro Groundsmaster 328D 72in Ride-On Mower (A44572)
2010 Toro...
2025 Wolverine TR-26-02C Class 2 Quick Hitch (A47484)
2025 Wolverine...
2011 Ford Expedition XLT SUV (A44572)
2011 Ford...
Variable Speed Conveyor Belt (5.5ft) (A46877)
Variable Speed...
 
Top