I would have took my drain plug down to the auto parts store got the next two oversized oil plugs and see which one had the best feel when threading them in. If you strip out the drain plug on a car or truck that is what just about everybody does. How often do you change the oil in your tractor 2 times a year? The oversized drain plug will not have any problems wanting to fall out on you. If feel that you could cause an oil leak at the oil pan gasket that would be alot worse than if the oversized drain plug did seep a little over time. I have not ever torqued an oil pan drain plug, just snug it up and away you go. The drain plug does not have to be tight like a nug nut. The drain plug in not under anykind of load. *All the drain plug does in stop up a hole. My 2 cents