I know guys that have done that. I've learned to charge batteries late winter and spring and whenever they don't get used much to keep a charge up. It's not uncommon that I have a battery go 10 or more years when I use my NOCO chargers.If your battery is completely dead I hook up jumper cables and hook it to a running truck for a few minutes.
Some newer chargers will give a Bad Battery light if there is 0 voltage.
I recently saved three battery's with the desulfate mode that I thought they were dead forever.
I figure my new $300 battery charger has paid itself off. It works
I'll see if holding that button down for six seconds for a dead battery.NOCO has a force charge mode. It will charge even if the battery is 0%. You just need to press the button for 6 seconds to enter this mode.
Reminds me of something I did many years back in my model building years. I had several small 6V lead acid batteries that I used in my model RC boats. They were used infrequently and after only 2 years, got to the point where they would no longer hold a charge. The battery cases were made of clear plastic and I could see white stuff covering the plates and black residue on the bottom. I didn't have much money back then and they cost too much for me to replace.Lastly, your old battery is tired and won't hold up for use and fails a load test. It's been on a charger for days and days and ya still can't get the specific gravity up? Maybe there's a bunch of build up on the bottom and 1+ failed cells? It must be sulfated or shorted internally, right? Has anybody broke an old battery open to verify any of the above? I haven't. I haven't heard of anyone doing that either. Have you?