Hey guys and gals,
This is just speculation on my part, cause I really don't know.
I think? that the deciding factor, as to wether your hydro tran. tractor has a conventional clutch or not, may be related directly to the type of PTO on the tractor.
From my limited experiance, it apears that until recently, the hydro tractors mostly used a clutch to allow engagement/disengagement of the PTO. My old 87 MF 1010 was this way. I could shift from HI to Low range with out the clutch, as long as the tractor was stopped, but had to use the clutch to engage/disengage the PTO if the engine was running. I think that some of the newer tractors have an electric switch/clutch on the PTO that allows its' use with out having a separate clutch. My new 4310 is a gear drive, power reverser tranny, but the PTO has a separate electric clutch on it, and it makes no difference if the mechanical clutch is engaged or not. When you pull up on the PTO switch, the PTO is engaged. In gear, out of gear, moving, stopped, clutch in or out, PTO switch is pulled, and away it goes. While this is nice for mowing, the mower keeps working, (until you push the PTO switch off), it also means I cannot feather or regulate the PTO engagement. Even at idle, when you pull the PTO switch, it starts the output shaft abruptly. Bad enough to have sheared the pin on my deck 5 different times during one days mowing. With the PTO activated by a manual clutch, I could regulate power to the PTO and ease on the torque, making spin up of the mower a lot easier on the deck.
Anyway, my thoughts on the clutch/no clutch issue. Looks like it depends on the PTO and not the range change gearing. All of the tractors I am familiar with (not too many) in order to change speed range on the tranny, gear or hydro, the tractor had to be stopped because there are no snycros on this gear box and it is not meant to be shifted on the fly.
This is just my speculation and maybe some partially spoiled food for thought.
Other ideas? Any expert witnesses?
DT