Tractor Sizing I have no clue...I need help!

   / I have no clue...I need help! #1  

Getbusyorgetfat

New member
Joined
Dec 24, 2015
Messages
4
Location
Trego, Wi
Tractor
none
I have just retired this past fall. I purchased 65 acres of mostly woods a few years ago to keep me busy during my retirement. I need to smooth out the trails I have cut already, move some dirt around, drag out dead fall, worry out and move some rocks, and plant and maintain a few small food plots for deer hunting. My mowing needs are covered for now, not great, but I can get by. Since money is a factor (I'm not poor or rich) I'd rather not spend money on a deck right now. I think I need a loader and a backhoe but not sure what else. I don't need to get the job done in record time. I just need to have enough hp that it can be done. The biggest food plot would not be much bigger than an acre. I do not plan on planting any row crops. I am leaning toward new or almost new. I have looked at some compact and sub-compact tractors so far. The price points have run the full gambit, from, "not bad" to, "how much" !!!!

This is essentially play time with a purpose for me. Nothing I do or can't do will make or break me out there. I do have ideas and plans and want to accomplish them and do a good job. Thanks in advance for any advice on sizing, implements, how to find a good dealer and anything else that you think I need to know.

Merry Christmas and God bless our troops!
 
   / I have no clue...I need help! #2  
I would look used. You can get a whole lot more tractor for less $$$. If I was buying another tractor I would look hard at the TLBs like a L45 or JD110. The TLBs are considerably tougher than a regular tractor. The TLBs aren't very good at field work, but kick *** with the loader and backhoe. If you want a regular cut sized tractor I would highly recommend my L3240 Grand. It would be a little small for mowing 65 acres, but you said you didn't plan on doing that. It could easily handle the other described task. It could mow 65 acres, but it would take a while. I mow 40 acres on a smaller tractor.
 
   / I have no clue...I need help! #3  
I have just retired this past fall. I purchased 65 acres of mostly woods a few years ago to keep me busy during my retirement. I need to smooth out the trails I have cut already, move some dirt around, drag out dead fall, worry out and move some rocks, and plant and maintain a few small food plots for deer hunting. My mowing needs are covered for now, not great, but I can get by. Since money is a factor (I'm not poor or rich) I'd rather not spend money on a deck right now. I think I need a loader and a backhoe but not sure what else. I don't need to get the job done in record time. I just need to have enough hp that it can be done. The biggest food plot would not be much bigger than an acre. I do not plan on planting any row crops. I am leaning toward new or almost new. I have looked at some compact and sub-compact tractors so far. The price points have run the full gambit, from, "not bad" to, "how much" !!!!

This is essentially play time with a purpose for me. Nothing I do or can't do will make or break me out there. I do have ideas and plans and want to accomplish them and do a good job. Thanks in advance for any advice on sizing, implements, how to find a good dealer and anything else that you think I need to know.

Merry Christmas and God bless our troops!

First off, welcome to TBN!

Second, do you have any prior experience with tractors or similar equipment?

A backhoe is a handy, but they're quite expensive, and many people find they don't use them very often...as in so few times they could rent a real backhoe once or twice a year for years and be money ahead. How many trenches or footings do you really need to dig, or are you planning to use it to dig out stumps?

As far as used versus new, I'm going to somewhat disagree with 4570Man. Right now, anything that's reasonably new goes for close to new prices. In late 2012 I bought a new LS R4047H, put 215 hours on it in 15 months, and sold it for $2K less than I paid for it. I don't see $2K getting you "a whole lot more tractor" for less, and there have been many similar stories related here recently.
 
   / I have no clue...I need help! #4  
Whenever I buy something, the first thing I do is look on craigslist, and I'm in the market for a sub compact utility tractor (scut) just like you. I have found in my area, which is southern WI, that used tractors hold their value very, very well. I've seen 10 year old tractors with 500 hours going for over 10,000 dollars, where you can buy new for 15G's. I almost never buy new, but after seeing the market, I am this time. Some great financing deals going on right now on most brands.

Go to your local dealers, test drive as many as you like. I am picking up a Massey Ferguson GC1715 on Monday morning. It sounds to me that a Massey 1710 or 1720 would fit your needs. Those two come equipped with a FEL (front end loader) and a BH (back hoe). The bigger 1720 is around 25 HP.

I spelled out some of acronyms folks on here use, just to get you familiar with them. Good luck and have fun looking. Growing food plots for deer will be easy and fun with your new machine.
 
   / I have no clue...I need help! #5  
While you are probably right about being money ahead renting a backhoe, it sure is nice having your own. I use mine all the time for jobs not worth renting a machine that other wise would get done with a shovel. Under the same logic most guys would be money ahead not owning a tractor at all and just renting one. I paid $16,000 for a L3240 Grand HST with a LA724 loader with about 200 hours. Another plus to used is you can get a machine a few years old that has been well cared for and avoid the EPA emissions crap. I'll take a $5000 dollar price reduction for 500 hours. As far is I am concerned as long as it has been garage kept 10 years old is a plus. No emissions crap.
 
   / I have no clue...I need help!
  • Thread Starter
#6  
Wow! More replies than I thought I would get this fast on Christmas Eve. Thanks alot for the replies and the model #s to check out. Any thoughts on the bare minimum implements I woud need to do the food plots? They have field grass that will be mown short and have never been tilled.
 
   / I have no clue...I need help! #7  
I have just retired this past fall. I purchased 65 acres of mostly woods a few years ago to keep me busy during my retirement. I need to smooth out the trails I have cut already, move some dirt around, drag out dead fall, worry out and move some rocks, and plant and maintain a few small food plots for deer hunting. My mowing needs are covered for now, not great, but I can get by. Since money is a factor (I'm not poor or rich) I'd rather not spend money on a deck right now. I think I need a loader and a backhoe but not sure what else. I don't need to get the job done in record time. I just need to have enough hp that it can be done. The biggest food plot would not be much bigger than an acre. I do not plan on planting any row crops. I am leaning toward new or almost new. I have looked at some compact and sub-compact tractors so far. The price points have run the full gambit, from, "not bad" to, "how much" !!!!

This is essentially play time with a purpose for me. Nothing I do or can't do will make or break me out there. I do have ideas and plans and want to accomplish them and do a good job. Thanks in advance for any advice on sizing, implements, how to find a good dealer and anything else that you think I need to know.

Merry Christmas and God bless our troops!

Welcome aboard and merry Christmas!! It's now 11:58 EST.

I bolded your pertinent points.

You really need to give us a few more factors for accurate advice.
Pics would help.

How big are your deadfalls? Do you want to drag or carry a 100' oak or will it be a 20' pine?
What size rock are we talking about? Baseball or Buick?
What do you have for local dealers? Brand and distance?
What are your wrenching capabilities? Can you field strip a tank or is changing a tire the most you can do?
What's the size of your trails and the density of your woods? Do you have 20' wide paths or narrow trails? Can you ride a bike through the woods or is so dense only a rabbit can get through?
What's your topography? Kansas Flat or Afghanistan mountainous?
And what do you plan to do with the backhoe?
Do you have a trailer and truck?
Do you have a barn/shed/shop to work on it in?
And maybe most of all give us a budget range of how much money we can tell you to spend :)

I'm in a similar situation in NE Mississippi, 70+ acres around the house, moderate hilly, trail maintenance and moving trees primarily.

Off the cuff I'd recommend a 40 to 50 engine HP tractor w/ a FEL, 4WD, probably HST. You don't want to go to big if you have to maneuver through the trees. You don't want to be to small if you are dragging trees.

I got this:
451540d1451020851-i-have-no-clue-i-img_20151207_150524186_hdr-jpg


1995 Kubota M4700, ~1400 hrs, 4WD, FEL 50HP, 2 remotes in the rear $11.5K and change in 2013. It will lift 1K kg on the FEL and 2K kg on the 3pt.

So far I've had to put about $1K into it for front tires, a new battery, hose, a FEL cylinder rebuild, etc. I've also put about $5K into attachments in my sig. A comparable new geared MX4800 would cost list about $35K WITHOUT ANY ATTACHMENTS. In 2 years I've put on about 200 hours. I couldn't justify spending an extra $20K on something that's basically a big toy.


I would look used. You can get a whole lot more tractor for less $$$. If I was buying another tractor I would look hard at the TLBs like a L45 or JD110. The TLBs are considerably tougher than a regular tractor. <snip>

TLB's of the size he needs are rare on the used market. I looked long and hard and could not find anything in decent condition.

First off, welcome to TBN!

Second, do you have any prior experience with tractors or similar equipment?

A backhoe is a handy, but they're quite expensive, and many people find they don't use them very often...as in so few times they could rent a real backhoe once or twice a year for years and be money ahead. How many trenches or footings do you really need to dig, or are you planning to use it to dig out stumps?

As far as used versus new, I'm going to somewhat disagree with 4570Man. Right now, anything that's reasonably new goes for close to new prices. In late 2012 I bought a new LS R4047H, put 215 hours on it in 15 months, and sold it for $2K less than I paid for it. I don't see $2K getting you "a whole lot more tractor" for less, and there have been many similar stories related here recently.

I bought a backhoe w/ my first tractor and I rarely use it so far. But i do have plans for it. To me the prime advantage of a backhoe on a tractor versus a mini-ex is if you have to travel any distance.

Figure out the biggest heaviest thing you will need to move and add 10%, then get a tractor that will move it. Going to small can be a deal breaker. If you have to move a rock that's 2'x2'x2' and weighs 1500 lbs you can always break it down smaller, but that's a big pain. In my case I needed to move 10' logs that weigh about a ton to my sawmill. Cutting them in half length wise would be a big pain.

Well now it is Christmas, 01:10EST.

Good luck, give more info.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20151207_150524186_HDR.jpg
    IMG_20151207_150524186_HDR.jpg
    463.8 KB · Views: 945
Last edited:
   / I have no clue...I need help! #8  
My 1715 is coming with FEL, Mid mount mower (MMM), and I also bought a Land Pride 50" tiller. The ultimate food plot, mowing machine, in my eyes anyhow.

$13,600 for the tractor, FEL, MMM, and $2000 for the tiller.
 
   / I have no clue...I need help! #9  
Congradulations on the 65 acres and the plans for retirement activity ! I do not intent to retire anytime soon, but if I do, I hope to stay active "on the land".
Merry Christmas from Nebraska.
 
   / I have no clue...I need help! #10  
If you are not going to plow anything you might want to consider a skid loader. IMO, they are a lot safer for the user, as you are caged in, land speed they are a lot more maneuverable, is not as fast as tractor, could go two speed high flow and come close. Have to go used to going backwards, If you plan on using the loader a lot, skid steer is the way to go. Then get small lawn tractor or splurge and get ZTR. Oh, almost forgot when I looked skid steer was more cost effective. Know you asked for a tractor and this a tractor web sit, had to get in my,:2cents:
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2025 Swict 78in Bucket Skid Steer Attachment (A50322)
2025 Swict 78in...
2002 Ford F-350 Crew Cab Pickup Truck (A50323)
2002 Ford F-350...
2017 Bad Boy Outlaw XP 61in Zero Turn Mower (A48082)
2017 Bad Boy...
John Deere 1110 Field Cultivator - Heavy-Duty Soil Finisher for Precision Tillage (A52128)
John Deere 1110...
Gleaner R50 Combine (A50514)
Gleaner R50...
2004 FORD F-650 SUPER DUTY DUMP TRUCK (A51406)
2004 FORD F-650...
 
Top