RPM, (remember this smiley-face throughout /w3tcompact/icons/smile.gif );
Well, no one could call your fancy-dancer obfuscations "mumbling"! /w3tcompact/icons/shocked.gif
But they could be described as descriptions of some of the "mysterious ways" often mentioned when no answer is available.
<font color=blue>Rocks I don't think would be a problem. You and me are supposed to be able to handle mountains: ..etc</font color=blue>
The quotes do not apply. The issue is not what you or I can do, with-or-without faith. The puzzle has a simple issue, relating to omnipotence. To stay with the stated problem; can a supreme all-powerful being create something so large, (symbolically. a ''rock") that he cannot "lift" it.
Obviously, being all-powerful this being should be able to create it . He should then be able to lift it. which would show that He had failed to create the "unliftable" rock, proving that He is not all-powerful.
On the other hand, if He succeeds in making it too heavy for Him to lift, His failing to be able to lift it again proves fallibilty.
Both cases are incompatible with the "given" powers.
There is no answer to be had, of course, ...the entertainment-value of this puzzle lies in observing the reactions to its being posed.
<font color=blue>we need to look at the wider problem</font color=blue>
Which, of course, insures that we won't look at the narrower one! /w3tcompact/icons/wink.gif
Just tryin to have a little fun, ...when I conceded to being outgunned by the "math-types" on this list, I should have included astro-physicists /w3tcompact/icons/tongue.gif .
Interesting stuff, though!
Larry