Is 4310 enough?

   / Is 4310 enough? #1  

siebo

New member
Joined
Jul 12, 2002
Messages
11
Location
SW Michigan
I am very interested in the 4310 ePowreverser and 430 fel. I have 13 acres of land, 7 of which I want to use a 7" rear finishing mower and 6 acres use a 6" light duty rotary cutter. My land is flat with no trees or anything to mow around. Just up and back. The dealer said that the 4310 would have no problem handling these impliments. Most people on this forum say you are better off going with more hp. The other tractor I am looking at is the TC40, which I also like very much. However, I feel that is an overkill for what I want to do. Any thoughts would be appreciated.
 
   / Is 4310 enough? #2  
The 4310 compares more with the New Holland TC33. 32 horsepower and 33 horsepower. I think the TC40 would be over kill. It is a class lll tractor where the TC33 is a class ll.

I agree that the 4310 or the TC33 would work for you. My suggestion would be to get both of them tractors under your seat, price them out and get comfortable with the dealers. You have to go for comfort, price and I think most important is your dealer. Both tractors are good but neither one is any good if your dealer doesn't back it up. You will find in this forum that John Deere, New Holland, Kubota and all others have good dealers and they all have bad dealers. You have to get comfortable with the one your want to purchase from.


murph
 
   / Is 4310 enough? #3  
Your short list is the same as mine was. We went to drive both and one was a clear winner. Yours could be differant.

There is a differance here, the Boomer is bigger, for me, that worked against it.

Dealers make a huge differance.

I think that the 4310 is up to the job. Even better if it is MFWD.
 
   / Is 4310 enough? #4  
"I want to use a 7" rear finishing mower and 6 acres use a 6" light duty rotary cutter."


Are you sure you only want to use a 7" (7 inch) or 6" (six inch) mower? I know you meant 7' or 6'. The JD 4310 is almost the same as what I am considering to run a 84" mower. The HP and torque are very similar. You should be fine. Rat
 
   / Is 4310 enough?
  • Thread Starter
#5  
RaT

Thank you for the correction. I did mean 7 feet and 6 feet.

John
 
   / Is 4310 enough? #6  
I agree with Murph. You need to operate both tractors on your property for an hour, not 5 minutes around the dealership's lot. Some dealers don't like the idea of their equipment out that long but you need that much time. A quick spin around the dealers lot won't tell you much about its handling, visibility, three point hitch operation and most importantly, the loader operation including attaching and detaching. This is especially true with the Supersteer feature on the NewHolland. I've posted a couple of times here about Supersteer. I have it on my TC40D. 90% of the time I absolutely love it. 10% of the time I hate it. The tight turning radius is incredible. But it has the quirk of the front end of the tractor actually turning in the opposite direction of your steering for the first few degree of the steering angle. 90% of the time it presents no problem and your drive around with this incredible smile on your face. Its that good. However, with a loader attached and in tight quarters, with the loader extended several feet in front of the tractor that little "quirk" can drive you nuts. If you drive up next to a building with a loaded bucket, with little room to spare on each side, and need to make a correction Supersteer can be frustrating in my opinion. You get better with a little experience but it never goes away. If you are too close for example on the right side and turn your wheels to the left (which is instinctively what you do) your bucket actually goes further to the right. If you are close to a building you can hit it which I've done a few times. Again, with experience, you plan your moves in advance and it lessens the problem. But once or twice a month (I use my loader constantly) I get caught too close to a building or tree and struggle to back up without gouging something with the bucket. On the plus side you can spin the tractor nearly in zero turn, its almost that good. I really enjoy my TC40D and would buy another. I have 180 hours on it and the only problem has been a need for an adjustment on the hydro pedal return springs. But before you buy I think you should get a good feel for the Supersteer feature before you buy it. My dealer sells 9 out of 10 class II and III boomers with Supersteer so most feel it is a good feature. In all likelyhood you won't see it as huge problem but you should take some to use it for a while especially if you ever plan to put a loader on it.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2005 JOHN DEERE 5205 TRACTOR (A51222)
2005 JOHN DEERE...
2014 Ford Explorer AWD SUV (A50324)
2014 Ford Explorer...
2020 VOLVO VNL760 SLEEPER (A51222)
2020 VOLVO VNL760...
2018 PETERBILT 579 SLEEPER (A51222)
2018 PETERBILT 579...
Hours : 1114 (A50323)
Hours : 1114 (A50323)
2014 UTILITY 53FT DRY VAN TRAILER (A51222)
2014 UTILITY 53FT...
 
Top