Hey Jim, I borrowed a destroking valve and destroked my pump, quiet as a mouse. put it back in stroke and it ran quiet for a week before getting even more noisy than before. Now comes the part I find hard to tell anyone. Since diagnostics said the pump seemed good I just started checkin everything that moved and found the water pump bearing failing. it only seems to squall when up to temp. I swear it sounded like the pump, even had my son listen. Many thanks for the repeated warning not to jump the gun.