Kubota Cab vs JD Cab

[EastTexFrank]

I've done some pretty heavy shoppping over the last couple of weeks and worked my new tractor purchase down to basically two : JD 4320 or the Kubota L4740. There is not much difference in the actual cost, the JD being slightly cheaper because of their $1,000 dollar rebate compared to Kubota's $300. I've sat in the JD and drove it around and like it a lot. The Kubota dealer didn't have a L4740 on the lot.
The thing is, I'm getting one with a cab this time (getting old) and the JD was an open station. I've no particular color preference although I have a better relationship with the Kubota dealer so the decision will come down to which has the better cab. So all you JD and Kubota cab drivers out there, what do you think of the merits of the two cabs, their ergomomics and especially the A/C and fitering systems? I would appreciate any advice or recommendations. Thanks in advance.

 

[elgin4420]

Very new to the list, but I can say I just ordered my JD4320 and I'll tell you that the cab is a little smaller, but the blower for the AC was MUCH better in the JD. Also, I thought it was much quieter then either the K or the NH.
I test drove a 4520, which is the same frame and cab and it was great! Helped me make my final decision.

Good Luck
mike..

 

[Builder]

You can get a DB rating on both cabs. Check the DB rating to determine which is quieter. Also check the seats as they are a huge factor in comfort.

 

[art]

The Kubota cab has the ability to shut out side air out for dusty conditions.
The six range transmission is optimum for work of all types.

 

[Kyle_in_Tex]

Copied from Jd Website

John Deere : ComfortGard™ Cab Tractors

Operator Station - ComfortGard Cab
ComfortGard Cabs are factory-installed on the tractors
Completely pressurized and sealed to keep cool (or warm) air inside and dust and allergens outside
15,000 BTU heater keeps you comfortable in the worst winter conditions
Extra-large condensers and blowers mean fast, efficient cooling in the summer heat
Exclusive raised head bar allows a clear view of the loader all the way to the top of the lift cycle
Independent testing proves the John Deere cab is 20 percent quieter than a comparable competitive model
Automotive-style comfort provides plenty of leg, elbow and headroom and all controls are within easy reach


You can option up to an air-suspension seat for about $500 too.

 

[MessickFarmEqu]

You can get a DB rating on both cabs. Check the DB rating to determine which is quieter. Also check the seats as they are a huge factor in comfort.

By the DB rating, the Kubota is quieter. Also a bit larger, and has more standard features like two steps, mirrors, etc which are optional on the green tractors. By closing off the outside air you can also cool the cab faster and too a lower temp than the Deere which does not have a recirculate function.

 

[EastTexFrank]

By the DB rating, the Kubota is quieter. Also a bit larger, and has more standard features like two steps, mirrors, etc which are optional on the green tractors. By closing off the outside air you can also cool the cab faster and too a lower temp than the Deere which does not have a recirculate function.

Now that's interesting!!!! I was kinda leaning towards the JD because I wanted a change. We already have 2 Kubotas, one at the house and one at the farm but the A/C is one of the main reasons for getting a new tractor for the house. This Texas heat is starting to affect me ..... a lot. It looks as if it is going to be orange again. Going to make the final decision in the next two weeks. Keep you posted.

 

[EddieWalker]

Frank,

Are you shopping at Rose County Kubota? They seem to be well run and always have parts on hand. I was curious why the stoped selling New Holland and Massey Furuguson's. Any idea why?

The New Holland dealer seems to have more and more tractors on his lot at the new location. He's over on 69 between the Loop and the Trade Days.

I've never had a cab tractor, but on my last vacation to South Dakota, Steph and I drove through allot of farm country, and there were only two types of tractors that we saw over and over again. Deere and New Holland. It was so rare to see red or orange that it became something that we really noticed.

Eddie

 

[Z-Michigan]

I've never had a cab tractor, but on my last vacation to South Dakota, Steph and I drove through allot of farm country, and there were only two types of tractors that we saw over and over again. Deere and New Holland. It was so rare to see red or orange that it became something that we really noticed.

Eddie

The regional differences continue to amaze me. In central Michigan I would say 80-90% of farm tractors are Deere. The rest are a mix of older Masseys, older and newer Agco Allis, and Fords (but few if any of the New Holland after they split from Ford). Kubota and IH are nearly absent from farm fields, even though there are two big nearby dealers for them that have farm-size tractors from each in stock.

I'm not trying to say anything about quality, FYI, and below 40hp Kubota has a significant market share here, though I think JD dominates even that size as well in my area.

 

[EastTexFrank]

No Eddie, I was shopping at Ballard's Tractor in Alba for Kubota and AG-Power in Mineola for Deere. I also shopped New Holland in Lindale. Those are the nearest 3 to the house. The nearest Massey dealer is in Longview. I've used a cab tractor at the farm but this will be the first one with a working A/C system. I'm really looking forward to that and that is why it is so important to me. The difficult thing is that neither dealer has a cab version of the model I'm interested in on their lot, hence the query here.

Z - around here I would say that Kubota has at least 60% of the market up to 100 hp, above that it is almost exclusively Deere with some Case but not many. The New Holland dealership opened in Lindale, about 12 miles away, a few months ago but hasn't made much of an impact to date.

I was in talking to the Deere dealer again today and, with the State Fair promotion they are running at the moment, they are significantly cheaper than Kubota but they can't (for some reason) give me a grapple or a grapple bucket on the model that I am intersted in and their delivery date is the 18th of December!!!!!. Strange ......

I'm going back to talk to the Kubota dealer at the beginning of next week and hopefully make a decision and plonk my money down the week after. I may be overworking this problem. My wife says I should just pick the one I like best and go with it. You gotta love her. Me, I still like to think that I'm going to end up with the best bang for my buck but to be honest, I think I could be happy with either one. The saga continues .......

I'll keep you informed as things work out.

 

[Kyle_in_Tex]

For me, the true test would be to set the machine in the hot Texas sun all day. At about 4 pm, start it up and see how long it takes to cool the cab when its 100 degrees outside and the sun shining thru the side windows.

I believe the deere is sealed off and pressurized too.

 

[EddieWalker]

Frank,

I was at Rose Country Kubota today buying some mower blades and I saw these two tractors sitting there. They were the only two cab models on the lot, and I just happened to have my camera with me. I don't know anything about them except the one on the left is a M7040 and the one on the right is a L5740.

Eddie

 

[babyfat]

which trans are you going with? go drive the new hydro from Kubota, very nice trans,

good luck happy shopping
John

 

[Gary51]

I just purchased a tractor from Rose in Tyler after pricing it from several East Texas dealers including Ballard. I think you will be pleasantly surprised at the price from Rose.

 

[EastTexFrank]

Thanks Eddie, I may run down to Rose Country Kubota on Monday. I'd really like to see the cab and sit in it before I make a decision. While I'm there I may as well ask what they can do for me as far as price goes.

Thanks for the heads up guys.

 

[EastTexFrank]

which trans are you going with? go drive the new hydro from Kubota, very nice trans,

good luck happy shopping
John

I'm going with the hydro. That's what I have on the B2400 and absolutely love it. I find it is a lot better than the glide shift with reverser that we have on the Kubota at the farm although even that beats the heck out of the non-synchromesh transmission we had on the old farm tractor

 

[BizDoc]

I believe the tractor, whether it be blue, green, or orange, will work comparable to the other, the cab on any will have minor differences, even with all the brand loyalty opinions, which ever is selected will be a fine tractor. But I have to say that now having a cab is a difference I would not go back from. I use my Kubota B3030hsdc whenever I like, and just today a neighbor with a Kubota was mowing a side hill without a cab, started in the cool of the morning, but by 11:00 had to quit, the 85 degree heat and the heat off the engine and transmission were just too much for him to continue mowing the field. It all comes down to personal preference in the end. You won't go wrong with NH (which I have previously owned), JD, or Kubota, all fine units. Find a dealer close by you can work with, a good dealer will make a good tractor a great tractor. Best wishes

 

[Double Orange]

Frank, I just got off my L5240 Cab. While grading I received a cell phone call and talked for over 1/2 hr. The other person on the call had no idea I was in a tractor with the engine and a/c running... now thats a sealed cab.
My Vote Orange!!
Frank

 

[Rara Avis]

I'm going with the hydro. That's what I have on the B2400 and absolutely love it. I find it is a lot better than the glide shift with reverser that we have on the Kubota at the farm although even that beats the heck out of the non-synchromesh transmission we had on the old farm tractor

If you are going to do anything that requires constant speed, such as feeding, fertilizing, et cetera....then make sure you get the cruise control feature...