Don't discount a Johnny Bucket. They turn a garden tractor into a pretty handy machine. You could get a Craftsman Garden tractor ,Johnny Bucket,GT box blade,wheel weights and a garden cart. you can get a lot of work done with a setup like this and still come in at around $5500.
The GT is what I am leaning toward. A full feature FEL is handy for lift height and capacity but the Johnny Bucket does move dirt. I was just quoted $175/weekend +$125/delivery of a CUT with FEL and one PTO/ 3pt attachment ...eg. scraper... from a local rental co.
Tractor shopping is the most humbling experience......