Sawyer Rob
Super Member
I ALWAYS lower mine, to take the load off it...
SR
SR
Leave the 3 point loaded?
- Thread starter def38
- Start date
- Views: 3203
OP
def38
Platinum Member
I've always thought that questions are not stupid, only some answers.
RickB
Super Star Member
- Joined
- Sep 18, 2000
- Messages
- 15,143
- Location
- Up the road from Dollar General WNC
- Tractor
- Just a Scag
Because no one would ever troll here. Actually I did not think the question was stupid, the way the post was phrased seemed to be the work of a troll. Describing an action, listing one negative direct result of that action then asking if the action is bad practice?
Then stand back and watch 5 or 6 pages of debate about leaving hydraulic attachments raised and unattended. Every single operators manual ever published for a tractor with a hydraulic system has admonitions against this very habit.
RTFM and decide.
kthompson
Elite Member
- Joined
- Sep 12, 2008
- Messages
- 3,509
- Location
- South Carolina
- Tractor
- Kubotas B2710, M6800, L6060 cab, Volvo EC excavator, 2 ZTRs and various implements.
I understand your thought there but disagree. There is always a safety issue any time you crank a tractor. It may be you brush up against the lift lever and the load drops. I use to do the same thing you do and one day realized the issue to the tractor and the safety issues also. (My wise father in law really helped me understand the issues) No longer do I leave any lift of any type raised. Any seal or hose can bust with no notice, even when machine is off resulting in load dropping hard with no warning.
WranglerX
Super Member
Its common practice to lower FEL to ground to take pressure of hydraulics when parking tractor... Why does not the same principle apply to 3PH....
Dale
Dale
wagne223
Platinum Member
Pretty much universally accepted in industry that suspended loads are a safety risk.
Also in any case where humans are working below an object that is lifted by hydraulics, there must be a mechanical safety mechanism in case of hydraulic failure.
Hose, seal and valve failures are rare but do occur.
There is no supporting evidence that the life span or condition of hydraulic components is increased with constant pressure.
There is evidence that increasing pressure, and time both have negative effects on hydraulic components.
For these reasons it is common practice to rest the load on the ground and relieve pressure when not actually in use.
On a more personal note, how are you going to feel if your dog or cat is sleeping under the attachment and it falls on the animal either from a seal failure or someone moving the lever?
I would be devastated. So I minimize that risk by placing all loads on the ground when i park my machine.
Also in any case where humans are working below an object that is lifted by hydraulics, there must be a mechanical safety mechanism in case of hydraulic failure.
Hose, seal and valve failures are rare but do occur.
There is no supporting evidence that the life span or condition of hydraulic components is increased with constant pressure.
There is evidence that increasing pressure, and time both have negative effects on hydraulic components.
For these reasons it is common practice to rest the load on the ground and relieve pressure when not actually in use.
On a more personal note, how are you going to feel if your dog or cat is sleeping under the attachment and it falls on the animal either from a seal failure or someone moving the lever?
I would be devastated. So I minimize that risk by placing all loads on the ground when i park my machine.
atsah
Elite Member
Leaving weight suspended for long periods of time leaving undo pressure on all components not to mention the weight will most likely move on it's own isn't a good idea, I see it all the time, more in the construction sector, employees not caring about it..
SmallChange
Platinum Member
- Joined
- Apr 19, 2019
- Messages
- 750
- Tractor
- New Holland WM25 with 200LC front end loader, filled R4 tires 43X16.00-20 and 25X8.50-14 (had a Kubota B6200D with dozer and R1 tires)
A further reason you might lower an implement that was left up for a long time, right before starting, would be that if it has drifted down, then as soon as the engine starts turning the lift mechanism would call for lifting action. That is, the control lever doesn't drift, only the implement. Thus at the moment of starting the control is demanding flow. This sounds like a bad idea, and at least would load down the starter motor and/or the engine whose oil has barely started flowing.
Just as a data point, I intentionally left my ballast box raised overnight, because I had filled it with concrete and used the top link and the adjustable lower link to get it nice and level so the concrete surface would be horizontal. Then I checked it first thing this morning. It had not drifted down any that I can tell. The tractor's quite new so seals should be their tightest. This was in a locked barn and was a special case, not a habit, just stating an observation here.
Just as a data point, I intentionally left my ballast box raised overnight, because I had filled it with concrete and used the top link and the adjustable lower link to get it nice and level so the concrete surface would be horizontal. Then I checked it first thing this morning. It had not drifted down any that I can tell. The tractor's quite new so seals should be their tightest. This was in a locked barn and was a special case, not a habit, just stating an observation here.