3RRL said:I don't think 4140 would be overkill.
If it was me, I would want it hardened, but pre-hard like 4140 or 4130 would probably do. What I don't like is that the pin is one length going through your tractor and those plates. If it bent you would have a heck of a time getting it off for replacement.
Which is one of my concerns as well. I don't know if the pin that came with the tractor is original but if it is 30 years later it is still perfectly straight.
Charles