Comparison Mahindra 1526 or Yanmar YT235 or Massey MF1734H

   / Mahindra 1526 or Yanmar YT235 or Massey MF1734H #11  
All in all I think all of the tractor manufacturers build quality products. I spent a lot of time on the web and TBN searching for the bad tractor brand, and couldn't find one. No matter what tractor people bought they seem pretty happy with them as a whole. The bottom line is a dealer you trust that has a good repair shop with quality mechanic when you need them. And which tractor meets your needs (comfort, ease of use, and capabilities) and fits in your budget. Sorry kinda sounds like a. copout, I heard it a lot when I was looking. We went from looking at 6 tractors down to three then two. We spent a little more for what we thought was the better tractor. We liked our dealer and their repair abilities plus it's only 15 minutes away. However I bought my tractor 3 hours away because I saved a lot of money. Now I just hope when I have an issue my local dealer still treats me right when I bring it in for repair?
 
   / Mahindra 1526 or Yanmar YT235 or Massey MF1734H #12  
Don't forget to compare spec sheets. You have some heavy work to do. Also, unless I'm mistaken, you're comparing a 26 HP Mahindra with a 35 HP Yanmar? Would explain the price difference!
 
   / Mahindra 1526 or Yanmar YT235 or Massey MF1734H #13  
I have heard that Mahindra's overpressure their pumps/lines to help with strength, and eventually (regularly) they fail.


Don't forget to compare spec sheets. You have some heavy work to do. Also, unless I'm mistaken, you're comparing a 26 HP Mahindra with a 35 HP Yanmar? Would explain the price difference!

A couple of thoughts that might help in the search.

Don't put too much emphasis on lift capability either with the FEL or the 3pt. If the brochure numbers are within 10 or 15% of each other chances are that they are so close to really being the same that you will never notice a difference.
For some mysterious reason, some manufacturers exaggerate all the time and others not at all. I won't name them, but in a few years you will figure it out. As for lifting specs, there isn't even complete agreement on how these are to be measured.

And if that weren't enough to mess up a nice spread sheet, there are a couple of really simple ways to fudge hydraulic system pressures and therefore lifting forces as well. We can go into them if you want to, but basically it doesn't matter if the brochure says one brand can lift 2500 lbs and another brand of tractor only 2000 lbs. In the first place they are probably about the same in the real world, and even if they are not it's only one extra trip out of every five - and probably more comfortable trips with the lesser weight anyway.

Something that hasn't been mentioned are the books that can come with the tractor. As you negotiate for the tractor, ask the dealer to throw in the "Factory Workship Manual" and the "Parts Manual" along with the usual "Operator's Manual". The first two are often worth a few hundred dollars, but will pay for themselves the first time that you have a question about what goes where.....or the next door neighbor comes over to help you figure out something on the tractor.
Neighborly Hint: Most experienced mechanics will pay most attention to the exploded illustrations in the Parts Manual, and then tend to refer to the Factory Workshop Manual when they need to look up a specification or a schematic or have some question about a procedure..

The quality of these technical publications vary dramatically between the different manufacturers. Some seem to treat them as an afterthought while others almost seem like they are personally wanting to teach people about their tractors. In the old days, JD and Yanmar were famed for the quality of their technical publications. It would be interesting to see who cares the most today.
rScotty
 
   / Mahindra 1526 or Yanmar YT235 or Massey MF1734H #14  
Did you buy something yet? I purchased my first tractor this year for my 11 acre spread. I went smaller because of all the trees, fences, hillsides, and tight turns so I bought a Yanmar SA 424. I really wanted to buy a Mahindra because they have a regional assembly and distribution facility in my town and I know the family that owns it and some of the people that work there. Someone on this site years ago wrote a thread about how to evaluate a tractor for your use. The first thing to do is drive the model your looking and really test the operator's station. Drive it forward and backwards, can you see and work the pedals without looking at them. Do the control pedals fit your boots? Are the mounting hand grabs in a good spot for you? How about the FEL control stick, will your arm get tired or sore after long use? What is the location of the fuel filler? For me the Yanmar has the superior ergonomics in the size class I was looking for and was less money than all the other brands except TYM and LS. I know next to nothing about the roughly 35hp range you are looking at but I think some of the manufacturers make power with turbo charging others with displacement ( I could be wrong on this point) and I'm not sure it matters but I would understand the tradeoffs if they did. This may be sacrilegious but I believe all the Japanese and Korean engines are excellent and I personally assumed they are all equal. It is true that Yanmar is a large supplier of power and transmission components to other OEM's and you will see that on some manufacturer's websites they list who makes the engine in the model description. the one thing I would make sure of is that your tractor has a quick release bucket on the FEL, the smaller of the two Mahindras did not when I was shopping last fall. Let's us know what you do.

Jim
 
   / Mahindra 1526 or Yanmar YT235 or Massey MF1734H #15  
Never mind I see you bought a Yanmar 359, sweet tractor.
 
   / Mahindra 1526 or Yanmar YT235 or Massey MF1734H #16  
Three red tractors, cool. Based on a cursory review of the specs they all seem pretty close in size/weight except obviously the 1526 is down 8-10hp compared to the Yanmar or Massey.

Two things. Understand what you're buying and make sure you're buying enough tractor. Yanmar makes Yanmar, builds everything from the wheels up in Japan.

The Mahindra is a rebadged Mitsubishi and the Massey is a rebadged Iseki with a Shibaura engine. They're all Japanese and the Japanese build good stuff. I personally prefer it when the name on the tractor is the company that actually built it.

Second, buy enough tractor. You mentioned that you needed to move hay and rock. What kind of hay? What kind of rock?

Just a little info on your statment that "Mahindra is a rebadged Mitsubishi" Mahindra bought 33% of Mitsubishi Ag back in 2015 so not sure if you can say its rebadged.

Mitsubishi Agricultural Machinery and Mahindra announce start of their strategic partnership | Mitsubishi Heavy Industries, Ltd. Global Website
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2018 Bobcat T595 (A50120)
2018 Bobcat T595...
KJ 20'x12' Livestock Metal Shed (A50121)
KJ 20'x12'...
2018 INTERNATIONAL 4400 4X2 EXT CAB SERVICE TRUCK (A51406)
2018 INTERNATIONAL...
2017 Jaguar F-Pace AWD SUV (A50324)
2017 Jaguar F-Pace...
44504 (A51692)
44504 (A51692)
2016 FORD F-450 9FT SINGLE AXLE DUMP BODY (A52141)
2016 FORD F-450...
 
Top