"Only time will tell how this all will pan out, but I have already let the kids, mostly Homestead Boys #1 & 2 that there is at least the possibility of us needing to re-home Scooter. There is not much else I could do with him, as he is too little to bother with meat. Hopefully that isn’t necessary." That is where the 'and dumplings' come into the picture. And about your spare JO rooster. If his bad traits outweigh his good ones, I wouldn't use him for breeding. But those same traits that make him a jerk, may be good in hens defending their space. The fast turnaround time in breeding chickens make it possible to hatch out a few and see how they turn out in just a few weeks.