my new tractor- manual vs hydro

   / my new tractor- manual vs hydro #61  
Re: my new tractor manual vs hydro

I think you've got it /w3tcompact/icons/smile.gif. However, the engine does provide braking, because it provides the movement of the fluid. I can't explain it well, so I dug out the manuals for my IH2500b(4cylinder gas engine, hydrostatic transmission, hi-lo range transmission, independant PTO rated at 50HP). Here's what it says in the operator's manual on page 22(if you have a book):

"Greatest efficiency of entire tractor, loader, and backhoe is at 2000 engine RPM and up, depending on desired speed of tools... the tractor forward and reverse travel speeds are controlled by range movement of the foot pedals or the Remote Drive Control Lever.

When pedal is not depressed, the transmission is in a locked or braked position.

Maximum torque and slowest travel speed is obtained with the least downward movement of the pedal.

Example: The least possible depression of the pedals will give you the slowest speed with the greatest torque to the drive wheels for digging or crowding into the stock pile or bank.

Using the tractor brakes is rarely required because:

As your foot moves upward from the hydrostatic pedal you are automatically decelerating your travel speed... and when your foot moves completely off the pedal, the pedal returns to the neutral or lock-up position and automatically brakes your transmission and travel."


It goes on on the next page to read:
"The hydrostatic transmission is designed so that: In high range the travel speed deceleration is less abrupt(slower) and the braking is more cushioned to prevent abrupt automatic braking."

"The cushioned braking and travel speed deceleration is timed with the automatic pedal return(or full-up position)

This definite time differential is designed into the system to not only provide the travel speed deceleration and cushioned stop but prevents accidental reversal of direction by the operator."

This is the part about the engine providing control at all times, which would include braking.

"The operator accustomed to mechanical or torque converter equipped tractor may be in the habit of reducing the engine speed for more positive control when operating in close quarters. This is neither necessary nor desirable with the hydrostatic tractor because the higher engine RPM will provide more positive control of not only the hydraulic tools but also the travel speed and automatic deceleration and braking. Maximum performance and control is achieved with high engine speed."


Whew!!! That was a load to type, but I thought you all might enjoy reading it.

I think I also answered my own PTO question, as the PTO on my IH2500b is powered by gears from the transmission, which is driven by the hydraulic pump. /w3tcompact/icons/smile.gif
 
   / my new tractor- manual vs hydro #62  
Re: my new tractor manual vs hydro

Rat, and all, thank you for your insight on this debate. Even a spin around the dealership lot would not show the benefit you've described. I have heard that HST is safer, now I understand. I currently own another variation, a Yanmar Powershift, which had led me to believe that a Syncro reverser would suit me. But I feel confident that I will stick with HST...
 
   / my new tractor- manual vs hydro #63  
Re: my new tractor manual vs hydro

<font color=blue>" the higher engine RPM will provide more positive control "</font color=blue>
I just have an old gear driven tractor but I think that this aspect of an HST would be the most difficult for me to get used to.
With an HST, does the operator get any "feedback" from the sound of the engine? I mean with my gear drive when the tractor starts "working hard" I hear the engine starting to work hard. What's the "feedback" in an HST?
 
   / my new tractor- manual vs hydro #64  
Re: my new tractor manual vs hydro

You can hear the engine working when things get more difficult. As the load increases the governer wants to keep it at the set RPMs, so vroom, the engine takes off. And there is always that pleasent hydrostatic whine. It is a sound made by most HSTs. You get use to it very quickly and begin to enjoy it. My little PT425 makes the same whine as my big IH2500b.
 
   / my new tractor- manual vs hydro #65  
Re: my new tractor manual vs hydro

Most definitely. The feedback is immediate and very similar to a gear drive. The biggest difference is that with the HST it is almost if not impossible to jerk the tractor. Start and stops are very smooth and the transition from forward to reverse and vice versa is again very smooth and very quick. One of the great benefits of HST for some implements like my powered landscape rake and delicate box blade work is the ability to control the speed. The speeds are infinite up to a maximum on mine of about 7 mph in medium. I find medium gets used about 70% of the time and the rest is high. I very rarely use low, its very low and I only needed it a few times while box blading backwards where I can really put a load on the rear tires.
Rat...

P.S. Moss, my L48 has no audible whine in medium or low unless I am against an immovable object. In high it is noticeable.
 
   / my new tractor- manual vs hydro #66  
Re: my new tractor manual vs hydro

Rat,
You have Kubota's HST which is the smoothest of the HST's I have driven - it's silky smooth. When you take your foot off, you don't jerk on the Kubotas, but all the other HST's I have driven DO stop quickly and, for me, uncomfortably including the NH I just bought. It's going to take some getting used to for me.
Mark

Hey, I just went to Silver!!!!!! WhooooHooooo!
 
   / my new tractor- manual vs hydro
  • Thread Starter
#67  
Re: my new tractor manual vs hydro

does the smaller tc25/29/33 h.h. tractors have syncro manual tranny's.the post above says they do?
 
   / my new tractor- manual vs hydro #68  
Re: my new tractor manual vs hydro

Per the NH brochure only the class III (35, 40 45) have the synchro transmission (12X12)

The class II (25, 29, 33) Have the "standard" gear trans (9X3)
 
   / my new tractor- manual vs hydro #69  
Re: my new tractor manual vs hydro

<blockquote><font size=1>In reply to:</font><hr>

<font color=blue>No, actually she cut off all the other body parts and left only the head. If she beheads me I'll be gone completely.</font color=blue>

<hr></blockquote>



Sounds like John Bobbitt..er maybe Bob Bobbitt./w3tcompact/icons/laugh.gif/w3tcompact/icons/wink.gif
 
   / my new tractor- manual vs hydro #70  
Re: my new tractor manual vs hydro

I can't remember exactly how my IH2500b sounds anymore, since I haven't driven it for a few years. I do now that it is too fast in high range(top speed of about 19MPH) to do any work. That is for road transport only, for sure. In low, it was a powerful brute.

My little PT425 has no ranges or transmission. Just an engine, hydraulic pump to hydraulic motors at each wheel and a forward and reverse pedal(2 more hydraulic pumps for hydraulic cylinders and PTO). But it has plenty of power to do the tasks that I need it to do, and that makes me /w3tcompact/icons/smile.gif
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2013 Dodge Journey SXT (A50324)
2013 Dodge Journey...
2018 KENWORTH T680 TANDEM AXLE SLEEPER (A51222)
2018 KENWORTH T680...
2008 FORD F750 SUPER DUTY BUCKET UTILITY TRUCK (A50854)
2008 FORD F750...
2018 Allmand Night-Lite V-Series S/A Towable Light Tower (A49461)
2018 Allmand...
Unused 2025 QK16R Mini Excavator (A49461)
Unused 2025 QK16R...
2019 INTERNATIONAL LT625 TANDEM AXLE SLEEPER (A51219)
2019 INTERNATIONAL...
 
Top