NAIS

   / NAIS #1  

jimg

Veteran Member
Joined
Jun 5, 2003
Messages
2,039
Ive been reading some in the news about the NAIS debate and understand some of the requirments the program will impose on stock owners. However, Im certain there are members here who know alot more and I wondered how it will effect you (and your operation). With what little I understand it seems a rather large program giving little benefit or perhaps misapplied to give little benefit. It also seems to be in a sort of mission creep mode in an attempt to justify its intent. Anyway, your input would be most appreciated.
 
   / NAIS #2  
I too have been reading about it. I have a feeling this will be like the Canadian gun registration database. It will cost billions and not work and be nothing more than a means to generate revenue through taxation of registered animals.

From what I have read, they want to register backyard chicken flocks to dogs and cats. When a direct question is asked. they say, "Don't worry about it, that is not its intent." Yet, you can see how it works its way down.

Here is what the state of TN is doing about it. This looks like something all the states should be doing.

HOUSE BILL 3297
>By Niceley
>
>AN ACT to amend Tennessee Code Annotated, Title 44,
>Chapter 7, relative to animal identification.
>
>WHEREAS, administered by the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA), the
>goal of the National Animal identification System (NAIS) program using Radio Frequency Identification (RFID) tags is to register every farm and every domesticated animal (including non-food animals such as horses) in a centralized database; and
>
>WHEREAS, the National Institute for Animal Agriculture (NIAA), composed primarily of
>large corporate producers and the makers and producers of animal identification equipment, lobbied the USDA to create the NAIS supposedly to protect U.S. citizens and their animals from disease; and
>
>WHEREAS, in April 2002 a task force composed of the Animal and Plant Health
>Inspection Service (APHIS) and over 30 livestock organizations created the proposed NAIS, while small-scale farmers involved in animal husbandry and animal hobbyists were not represented; and
>
>WHEREAS, farming is an honorable occupation and a right of all Tennessee citizens, and
>
>WHEREAS to protect the food supply of Tennessee and the United States from terrorism or disease it may be necessary to require Tennessee farmers to use an Animal Identification System that ensures less than 48 hour trace-back of any diseased animal, nevertheless such a system first, must not rob Tennessee citizens of their existing common law rights; second, cost farmers, stockyards, producers, processors, and consumers the least possible expense; third, leave Tennesseans secure in their privacy; and fourth, fit into the existing marketing structures of the Tennessee livestock industry without disruption, and
>
>WHEREAS, metal ear tags like those used to eradicate Brucellosis and Tuberculosis in the State of Tennessee cost only pennies and have already proven effective in eradicating disease, and
>
>WHEREAS Radio Frequency Identification (RFID) tags are many times as expensive as metal tags, untested, vulnerable to breakdown, defeat, and falsification, require expensive reading equipment, and do not constitute a reliable alternative for the Tennessee livestock industry,
>
>
>THEREFORE BE IT ENACTED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE STATE OF TENNESSEE:
>
>SECTION 1 Definitions. As used herein, unless the context otherwise requires:
>
>a. "Point of Entry Into Commerce" means sales at a stockyard, sale barn, or sale facility. It also denotes sales where the number of animals sold will constitute a "truckload" or more, whether sold to in-state or out-of-state buyers. Point of Commerce shall not include farmer-to-farmer sales or direct farmer-to-consumer sales.
>
>SECTION 2. Tennessee Code Annotated, Title 44, Chapter 7, is amended by adding
>the following as a new, appropriately designated part:
>Section 44-7-501. At no time shall department of agriculture funds or any other
>state funds be appropriated to implement the National Animal Identification System (NAIS).
>
>SECTION 3: All animals entering the point of entry into commerce shall be tagged on the ear with a metal tag containing a fifteen digit number consistent with the proposed NAIS, identifying at least the seller and the animal.
>
>SECTION 4: For purposes of Section 3, no seller of any animal may be required to register his farm or premises as a precondition of selling said animal.
>
>SECTION 5: For purposes of Section 3, those animals sold by the truckload in private sales or cooperative sales must be tagged by the purchaser of said animals, not the seller. If the purchaser of said animals fails to tag them they shall be fined not more than $50.00 per animal.
>
>SECTION 6: Information collected when tagging animals at the point of entry into commerce shall be forwarded to the United States Department of Agriculture Animal Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS) for processing, analysis, storage, and trace-back.
>
>SECTION 7: For purposes of Section 6, purchasers at the point of entry into commerce are not required to gather or forward data to APHIS until APHIS is prepared to accept that data. Should APHIS fail to make itself able to accept and manage the livestock tagging data, the Legislature may decide who in Tennessee will manage that data.
>
>SECTION 8: No animals except those sold for food at a point of entry into commerce shall be required to be tagged in the State of Tennessee.
>
>SECTION 9: No livestock producer in the state of Tennessee shall be denied veterinary or other services or medication, feed, goods, or any other needs because that producer's livestock is not tagged, unless that producer is attempting to enter the animal into the point of entry into commerce.
>
>SECTION 10. This act shall take effect upon becoming a law, the public welfare requiring it.
 
   / NAIS
  • Thread Starter
#3  
>>From what I have read, they want to register backyard chicken
>>flocks to dogs and cats. When a direct question is asked. they say,
>>"Don't worry about it, that is not its intent." Yet, you can see how
>>it works its way down.
This makes no sense to me since the program was envisioned to protect the food supply. How do dogs and cats figure in? As you said tagging that many animals is a reasonable time is going to be very difficult. Then theres the on-going work of registering large flocks of poultry every few weeks. Then theres the potential of making sure the database is correct and having the feds come after you b/c theyre records are wrong. Protecting our food sources is a good thing but this doesnt seem to be the right way of going about it.

>>Here is what the state of TN is doing about it. This looks like
>>something all the states should be doing.
This seems a good approach. I also read about another state (TX I think) thats mulling over whether to opt out completely.
 
   / NAIS #4  
I am seeing indications that the "animal rights" groups are among those pushing this. They see it as a way to eventually end all human ownership and consumption of animals.

Vernon
 
   / NAIS
  • Thread Starter
#5  
Hadnt read anything about this aspect of it.

Anyway, I know there are folks in this forum who own animals and I wondered if NAIS is on your radar yet and how youre going to deal w/ it. I suspect the big/commercial producers have been mulling it over for quite some time but the very small/owner-consumers probably havent. I suspect most everyone in this forum isnt a big/commercial operation. Id really be interested to know how youre going to proceed and if youve calculated the cost (if that even matters).
 
   / NAIS #6  
As for the big producers: I read that they do not have to tag every animal since they have internal bio-security protocols, and get one large umbrella ID. I could be wrong on this, but that's how I comprehended the information. Most cattle operations small and large keep detailed records, so this NAIS stuff is a large scale punishment for the few who don't keep records. Big Brother his here! (1984).


Joe
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

10x16.5 Tire Assembly (A46878)
10x16.5 Tire...
2021 DURAHAUL STEEL END DUMP (A47001)
2021 DURAHAUL...
2018 INTERNATIONAL LT625 SLEEPER (A43005)
2018 INTERNATIONAL...
New Holland T4.75 (A46443)
New Holland T4.75...
Two Sandblasters (A45336)
Two Sandblasters...
12-16.5 SKS9 Tires (A47809)
12-16.5 SKS9 Tires...
 
Top