Neighbor called the Law on me for shooting

[two_bit_score]

That is something completely different. In one hand we are discussing the legalities of police asking for ID with an articulatable and reasonable thought that the person in question may be a suspect in a crime. In the above, there is clearly a reasonable thought that the person answering the door may be a victim or suspect of a crime.

Two different things

How would the officer know the difference if he didn't ID the person who answered the door?