Newbie looking for advice
- Thread starter Pops15
- Start date
- Views: 5594
Ken45101
Elite Member
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2009
- Messages
- 3,669
- Location
- southern Ohio
- Tractor
- Kubota M5040, M9540, B21 TLB, B2710, RTV900, JD 325 Skid steer, KX-121-3 mini excavator
Agreed. Those three are probably the main ones with quality implements although there are a few other lesser known brands.
Realize too that each of them makes light, medium, and heavy duty. They also rate their implements for certain tractor hp ranges. You don't want to put an implement rated for 30 hp on a 50 hp tractor. When I started out, I bought a cheap scraper blade (TSC, before they put hp ratings on their stuff). I was a frequent customer at the local weld shop
Since I upgraded to a Woods medium duty scraper, nothing has broken in ten years Ken
Egon
Epic Contributor
The belly mower is usually a little handier when mowing lawns and getting close to things except for those cases where a rear mount can be backed in.
Installing/removing would be my main worry although I have never worked with such a large mower so it's smoke I,m blowing there.
Using the tractor for business I would suspect it will get used more than you anticipate requiring frequent removal of the belly mower as they are not compatible with most other jobs.
MarkV
Super Member
- Joined
- Apr 7, 2000
- Messages
- 5,636
- Location
- Cedartown, Ga and N. Ga mountains
- Tractor
- 1998 Kubota B21, 2005 Kubota L39
Pops welcome to the forum. Another issue with belly mower combination you are considering is weight. When you get into the 40-50 hp tractors weight and maneuverability don't lend them selves well to finish mowing. You will also find you can buy a dedicated riding mower for less the the cost of the belly mower.
You may want to take a look at the Kubota tractor/loader/backhoe series. Kubota Tractor Corporation - TLB Series - Loader/Landscaper Tractors Unless your jobs require a full size yellow TLB one of these may be able to meet both of your tractor needs.
Best of luck on your search.
MarkV
You may want to take a look at the Kubota tractor/loader/backhoe series. Kubota Tractor Corporation - TLB Series - Loader/Landscaper Tractors Unless your jobs require a full size yellow TLB one of these may be able to meet both of your tractor needs.
Best of luck on your search.
MarkV
jinman
Rest in Peace
- Joined
- Feb 23, 2001
- Messages
- 20,387
- Location
- Texas - Wise County - Sunset
- Tractor
- NHTC45D, NH LB75B, Ford Jubilee
With your list of attachments, it sounds like you are needing a tractor for serious work. I'm very opinionated about the New Hollands I know something about. My favorites are the 3040 and 3045. If I had lots of money and wanted a tractor to show off, I'd consider the Boomer 8N. There is no way on a good day that I'd consider it as a workhorse tractor. You'll pay $10k more for it and get nothing in return but people telling you how "purdy" it is.
A 3045 would be a good choice for you, but a 3040 may be even better. I think you will come to love the HST transmission and ergonometric features of that tractor. The Boomer 3040 has an MSRP of just $20,395 and is the best dollar-for-dollar. It has the same FEL and 3PH specs as the 3045 but the 3045 will cost you about $1500 more and the only difference is 5 more hp for PTO implements and a little more weight. Both have 4-cyl engines with the 3045 engine having a slightly longer stroke.
I think any of these tractors is probably not a good choice for a belly mower, but you can get the 3040 and 3045 with a mid-PTO if desired. You can also get them with the SuperSteer option that pivots the front axle and gives you an extremely short turning radius and automatic 4wd on demand. For dirt working tasks, having the brake pedals on the left and the HST pedal on the right will allow you to do dirtwork and use differential brakes for steering when the front end gets light. This is not possible on many CUTs. With the money you save not buying the Boomer 8N, you can put a very nice cab on the 3045 and find a use for those extra 5 engine hp beyond the PTO.
I'm not a big fan of 4-in-1 buckets because I think a grapple will do much of what they do and be more flexible for many other jobs you'd have as a contractor. Even a small grapple added to your regular dirt bucket will be a tremendous asset. You must, however, remember that the loader (250 TL) on these tractors will lift only 2000 lb at the arm pins and when you add a bucket, you can expect your lift to be more like 1600 lb or slightly less. You cannot lift a ton or more of materials on pallets off a truck. For that, you'll need the 4050 or 4060 tractor with a larger loader. However, your 3040 or 3045 will handle round bales on a FEL spear with ease. I've offloaded them 2-high off a flatbed trailer with no problem whatsoever.
If I were you, I'd shop around and then bring issues and questions back to these forums for info from the experience of this group.
A 3045 would be a good choice for you, but a 3040 may be even better. I think you will come to love the HST transmission and ergonometric features of that tractor. The Boomer 3040 has an MSRP of just $20,395 and is the best dollar-for-dollar. It has the same FEL and 3PH specs as the 3045 but the 3045 will cost you about $1500 more and the only difference is 5 more hp for PTO implements and a little more weight. Both have 4-cyl engines with the 3045 engine having a slightly longer stroke.
I think any of these tractors is probably not a good choice for a belly mower, but you can get the 3040 and 3045 with a mid-PTO if desired. You can also get them with the SuperSteer option that pivots the front axle and gives you an extremely short turning radius and automatic 4wd on demand. For dirt working tasks, having the brake pedals on the left and the HST pedal on the right will allow you to do dirtwork and use differential brakes for steering when the front end gets light. This is not possible on many CUTs. With the money you save not buying the Boomer 8N, you can put a very nice cab on the 3045 and find a use for those extra 5 engine hp beyond the PTO.
I'm not a big fan of 4-in-1 buckets because I think a grapple will do much of what they do and be more flexible for many other jobs you'd have as a contractor. Even a small grapple added to your regular dirt bucket will be a tremendous asset. You must, however, remember that the loader (250 TL) on these tractors will lift only 2000 lb at the arm pins and when you add a bucket, you can expect your lift to be more like 1600 lb or slightly less. You cannot lift a ton or more of materials on pallets off a truck. For that, you'll need the 4050 or 4060 tractor with a larger loader. However, your 3040 or 3045 will handle round bales on a FEL spear with ease. I've offloaded them 2-high off a flatbed trailer with no problem whatsoever.
If I were you, I'd shop around and then bring issues and questions back to these forums for info from the experience of this group.
Ken45101
Elite Member
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2009
- Messages
- 3,669
- Location
- southern Ohio
- Tractor
- Kubota M5040, M9540, B21 TLB, B2710, RTV900, JD 325 Skid steer, KX-121-3 mini excavator
And I think a 4-n-1 bucket is significantly heavier than a standard bucket and will further subtract from your lifting ability.
Ken
Ken
OP
Pops15
Platinum Member
- Joined
- Oct 10, 2009
- Messages
- 645
- Location
- IL
- Tractor
- Ford 555 TLB, Caterpillar Motor Grader, Kubota L245, Ford LGT 125, FABTEK aerial platform
Thanks for all the great info!
I realize I'll have to compromise in certain areas. The alternative is having separate tractors for different tasks. Now that would be fun if I had the budget for it...but I don't.
My thinking on the belly mower is I could put it on after construction and grading was done. Once that happens I don't anticipate doing much dirt work so I don't think I'd be taking the mower off and putting it back on very often. Part of my property is heavily wooded, and part is partially wooded. I figured a belly mower would be more manuverable than a 3pt finish mower in the sparsely wooded areas.
Where does a flail mower fit into the mower spectrum?
I've seen some awesome zero turn mowers. I'm not against going that route for finish mowing. How are they on rolling terrain?
I hadn't given any thought to a cab. I love being outdoors, but I can see the benefits of having A/C and heat in extreme weather conditions. A cab could cause issues when I go into the woods to drag out timber. I'll take a look at tractors with and w/o cabs.
I especially like the info about the hst and the brakes.
An 8N is $10K more? Thats crazy!!! Especially in this economy.
Also good info on the different duty ratings of attachments. As a contractor I know not to buy light duty tools.
I'll take a look at Kubota and other brands. I've rented Kubota's and NH's for grading work. Both were top notch for the jobs I used them for.
My neighbor has a 45HP Mahindra. Its been a great tractor for his needs but the thing is a monster. His property is flatter and much clearer than mine. The same HP NH looks to be smaller, lighter and more nimble.
I am locked in on the idea of getting a full size TLB so I won't be getting a BH for the compact.
I wasn't aware the lift specs on the loader didn't include the bucket. I know a couple of excavating contractors that have 4 in 1's on their grading tractors and they love them for finish work. Of course they have other machines for heavy duty loading and digging.
Any thoughts on buying used VS new? Looks like there are a lot of tractors for sale with 200-300 hours on them.
Is there a certain time of the year thats better to buy than others? It will be spring before I'm ready to buy.
Thanks for the welcome and all the good input!
Pops
I realize I'll have to compromise in certain areas. The alternative is having separate tractors for different tasks. Now that would be fun if I had the budget for it...but I don't.
My thinking on the belly mower is I could put it on after construction and grading was done. Once that happens I don't anticipate doing much dirt work so I don't think I'd be taking the mower off and putting it back on very often. Part of my property is heavily wooded, and part is partially wooded. I figured a belly mower would be more manuverable than a 3pt finish mower in the sparsely wooded areas.
Where does a flail mower fit into the mower spectrum?
I've seen some awesome zero turn mowers. I'm not against going that route for finish mowing. How are they on rolling terrain?
I hadn't given any thought to a cab. I love being outdoors, but I can see the benefits of having A/C and heat in extreme weather conditions. A cab could cause issues when I go into the woods to drag out timber. I'll take a look at tractors with and w/o cabs.
I especially like the info about the hst and the brakes.
An 8N is $10K more? Thats crazy!!! Especially in this economy.
Also good info on the different duty ratings of attachments. As a contractor I know not to buy light duty tools.
I'll take a look at Kubota and other brands. I've rented Kubota's and NH's for grading work. Both were top notch for the jobs I used them for.
My neighbor has a 45HP Mahindra. Its been a great tractor for his needs but the thing is a monster. His property is flatter and much clearer than mine. The same HP NH looks to be smaller, lighter and more nimble.
I am locked in on the idea of getting a full size TLB so I won't be getting a BH for the compact.
I wasn't aware the lift specs on the loader didn't include the bucket. I know a couple of excavating contractors that have 4 in 1's on their grading tractors and they love them for finish work. Of course they have other machines for heavy duty loading and digging.
Any thoughts on buying used VS new? Looks like there are a lot of tractors for sale with 200-300 hours on them.
Is there a certain time of the year thats better to buy than others? It will be spring before I'm ready to buy.
Thanks for the welcome and all the good input!
Pops
jinman
Rest in Peace
- Joined
- Feb 23, 2001
- Messages
- 20,387
- Location
- Texas - Wise County - Sunset
- Tractor
- NHTC45D, NH LB75B, Ford Jubilee
Well, you've hit on the one superior feature I know about a 4-in-1. You can do limited grading with it as long as you don't require tilt.
I like the idea of buying used. But you have to consider that you won't have the warranty of a new tractor, and the best financing deals (0% and such) are also only on new tractors. A used tractor has to be such a good deal that the warranty and financing don't matter.
MtnViewRanch
Elite Member, Advertiser
- Joined
- Mar 19, 2005
- Messages
- 10,648
- Tractor
- Mahindra 7520, Mahindra 3215HST, Case 580 extendahoe, Case 310 dozer, Parsons trencher, Cat D6,
Pops, one other thing, and I think that it has already been mentioned.
Typically a belly mower is used for finish mowing on a nice lawn.
Typically a nice lawn does not get mowed with a tractor that weighs as much as the tractors that you are considering.
Now none of this means anything, and you can do what you want to do, but there are reasons why some things usually aren't done a certain way.
And again as someone pointed out, you could most likely get a dedicated mower for what that belly mower [(MMM) Mid Mount Mower] would end up costing you.
As far as a flail mower, you can get ones that are for cutting a lawn and you can get them that will chop up bigger than 2" stuff. They are a lot closer to the back end of the tractor and are easier to maneuver than a Bush Hog type rotary cutter.
Just more stuff to ponder.
Typically a belly mower is used for finish mowing on a nice lawn.
Typically a nice lawn does not get mowed with a tractor that weighs as much as the tractors that you are considering.
Now none of this means anything, and you can do what you want to do, but there are reasons why some things usually aren't done a certain way.
And again as someone pointed out, you could most likely get a dedicated mower for what that belly mower [(MMM) Mid Mount Mower] would end up costing you.
As far as a flail mower, you can get ones that are for cutting a lawn and you can get them that will chop up bigger than 2" stuff. They are a lot closer to the back end of the tractor and are easier to maneuver than a Bush Hog type rotary cutter.
Just more stuff to ponder.
Ken45101
Elite Member
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2009
- Messages
- 3,669
- Location
- southern Ohio
- Tractor
- Kubota M5040, M9540, B21 TLB, B2710, RTV900, JD 325 Skid steer, KX-121-3 mini excavator
If you can find the right tractor with 2-300 hours on it at the right price, that's good. When I've been looking, I've only found 20+ year old stuff that looks like it's been through a couple of wars. Also consider warranty, 0% financing and/or good rebates that are available on new tractors. Personally, it's worth a thousand or two to me to get something that I know is in good shape and has a warranty.
Probably now is a good time to buy, the economy sucks, inventory is moving slowly and not many people buy this late in the season. Come spring, dealers will be hoping for more buyers and I would think they would not be making as good of deals. Of course, the economy could be worse in spring and there might be better deals, but I suspect not.
Ken
Probably now is a good time to buy, the economy sucks, inventory is moving slowly and not many people buy this late in the season. Come spring, dealers will be hoping for more buyers and I would think they would not be making as good of deals. Of course, the economy could be worse in spring and there might be better deals, but I suspect not.
Ken
