quicksandfarmer said:
We have poison ivy all over our farm. It would not be an overstatement to say that Zanfel has revolutionized our life. Unlike anything else that has existed before, it is a cure, not a sympton reliever. Zanfel removes the irritant in poison ivy, urushiol, from your skin. The conventional wisdom was that the urushiol dissipated rather quickly, and that unless you washed within a few hours of contact there was nothing you could do. Zanfel proves the conventional wisdom wrong -- at any point in an outbreak, Zanfel removes the urushiol, providing immediate relief and the symptoms disappear within hours.
I'm not sure that I agree with that explanation. But, let me say this, if it works for you, doesn't hurt you and is cheaper than a doctors visit, then it doesn't matter what the explanation is. If it works, use it, cause you can't argue with success.
However, almost anything will remove the oil from your skin. Any soap will remove it. So I'm not sure that I buy that the Zanfel removes it any better than soap. Also, I'm not sure where the conventional wisdom comes from that says the oil dissipates easily. I was taught, and it is my experience, that it will hang around a long time on skin, clothing and even a pet's hair. Now, removing the oil is
the first line of treatment but again, warm soap and water will do that. So technically, after a warm soapy shower, there is nothing to remove and in that regard 'cleaning' would have no effect on a reaction that has already begun. At that point the only intervention that will work is something that interferes with the body's immune response such as corticosteroids and antihistimines.
Now, there is nothing to say that Zanfel
doesn't have an effect on the immune response. And if it works and people are buying it, the company will unlikely take the time to explore that avenue due to the costs involved.
Don't get me wrong, I'm not knocking it. I'm all for anything that works. I'm just not sure the explanation, well, explains how or why it actually works. And, if it works that well, i may get some to keep in the cabin.
Some studies show that aluminum chloral-hydrate, which is the active ingredient in antiperspirents will prevent contact dermatitis if applied before exposure. There was even a prescription only product for a while. I'm not sure it ever really worked and it may be that higher dosages were neede to be effective and covering oneself with something that keeps you from sweating in the summer could lead to other more serious problems.
I think IslandTractor is also a doctor and if I remember correctly he might be an allergist. I'd like to hear his thoughts on contact dermatitis.