I just went through this with my bota. I zeroed out a front tire this last week end when moving snow. I could not get a new tire of the same brand as stock and the bota dealer said that he could not get one with out a rim in it!? I went to the local tire supplier and we looked at what he had. The front tires are 10-16.5 and when we put them next to each other there was about a 1 inch difference when not inflated. I was worried about that much difference and the possible binding it could put on the transfer case, and I would need two new fronts as not to drive the diff all the time.
The rule of thumb that the tire people go by here is 5% allowance on 4x4 between front and back when looking at the damiter. That made the 1 inch in 30 3%.
One thing of interest in the 3130, the stock tires are only 6 ply from the dealer, man, that is a light tire.
We put the new 10 ply tire on the rim and inflated the tire and there is very little difference when mounted. Bought two and off we went.
The tires that I put on are anvil wall, 10 ply, stronger and less expensive the stocker ones.
I have been very happy with the new ones.
Any way I got off track. Measure the diameter of both the front and the back and do a calculation, is it with in 5% (rule of thumb here)?
If it is as them what the allowable difference is, or maybe the poster that is a JD tech could let us know what JD thinks as it would be a number supplied by a non biased reference.
If it is with in the 5% or the allowable difference that JD states then you have weakened their argument.
Did the dealer remember you talking to them before changing the rear tires?
Sorry that this is so long.
Dane