If you’re in the select group that will you can buy a 7x series John Deere mower. I think those are an incredibly poor value.
if one is able to use a zero turn, which I can't, I'd agree with you. But it comes down to alternatives for one handed driving.
I wanted diesel and a 60 inch deck. Try finding one....Maybe the Simplicity does now but the Deere X700 diesels are just the new versions of the
older 400 series JD garden tractors with diesels that everyone raves about. But they aren't easy to find...and I bought a new farm and needed a mower
right then. Kubota doesn't/didn't make a 60 deck for their diesel rider, plus the JD looks heavier duty.
I have 650 hours on my X750, the simplest 2wd normal steering version they make, and hopefully the most reliable. And hopefully in twenty years someone will
be singing its praises too. But yes, spending 13 grand on a lawn mower when one has three other tractors for other work was a real gulp, but bought a new tractor lately?
I don't mind paying more if I get the quality, it's paying 5 grand, a huge amount of money for many (I'm a retired financial planner and truly understand home finances)
which means missing a vacation or not getting a new truck that year, and then the thing breaks in two years? Now that is seriously frustrating.
I've been studying this market for 30 years. Quality seems to start at the 300 level with JD, improves with 500 and gets plain impressive with the 700 series.
Very tried and true engineering, doing the same thing for a long, long time. I used to own a JD LX280 with a Kawasaki engine (equivalent to current 300 series)
that is now owned by a close friend who bought it, performs flawlessly after more than ten years. All of which assumes you grease your zerks religiously, blow out the engine ducts with air after each time you use it, etc. And how many folks honestly do that? Likely most of us...
The only other options for quality garden tractors appears to be Simplicity and Kubota.
Used to be certain companies "didn't build junk". Like Cub Cadet. I own a 1968 125 btw... and a 2017 X2, which I loaned to an elderly friend.
My local Kubota dealer also sells CC, and their service manager just rolls his eyes when you mention CC. Problem is almost always the least expensive models, built
to the lowest possible cost. In that arena, I'd rather buy a JD than a CC. But if anyone expects one of those JD's sitting in front of Home Depot, the D130's of this world to last ten years trouble free, well best of luck. It might, if you really take care of it.
For an elderly operator, trouble free operation will require someone making sure basic maintenance is being done.