motownbrowne
Elite Member
- Joined
- Dec 30, 2013
- Messages
- 2,613
- Location
- river falls, wi
- Tractor
- Kubota mx4700 HST, New Holland TC-29D
Check with the DNR for timber programs.
The numerical tests contained in the IRS hobby loss rules are merely "safe-harbors" and have been around for a long time...note the language that says "presumed". Meet them you are fine. Fail to meet them, then you might have to explain. That "presumed" thing in the underlying tax law is a "rebuttable" presumption.I guess my question to that would be how can that be possible with say a Christmas tree farm? It takes 6 to 10 years to grow a mature tree, so that's 6 to 10 years before a profit is even possible.
There must be some specific guidance out there for Christmas tree growers. Being a tree they might get special treatment, otherwise you probably have to defer (capitalize) all expenses until you start selling trees. I think whiskey works that way.I guess my question to that would be how can that be possible with say a Christmas tree farm? It takes 6 to 10 years to grow a mature tree, so that's 6 to 10 years before a profit is even possible.
As someone who makes their income farming vegetables, which is an area that has lots of hobby farmers, I'd like to respectfully ask you and other readers who are in a similar situation (comfortable off-farm income, producing for a hobby and write off) to not undercut the prices of producers who rely on this income. It's not uncommon for someone in this area to retire from a very comfortable job and start raising bees for example. Then they come to the farmer's market and sell for 25% less than the other vendors. They don't care of they aren't making a profit, but it has the potential to mess things up for the other vendors who need to maintain profitably to continue doing business. Just something to think about. Good luck with your new property.
Very good point!!!!
Thanks Richard, I appreciate you saying so. We have a strong reputation, and usually have no problem marketing our products (mostly wholesale), but many growers I know who sell retail often encounter this. It's very frustrating to complete against someone who's operating at a loss.