There's a right way and then there is the GOV. way

   / There's a right way and then there is the GOV. way #11  
NORTH PARK LAKE:

North Park Lake: located in Hampton, McCandless and Pine Townships, Allegheny County, Pennsylvania – was created by Allegheny County in the 1920’s. The signature piece of this 3,010 acre county park is its lake. North Park Lake is a man-made lake at the confluence of Pine Creek and the North Fork of Pine Creek. When first constructed in 1935, the surface area of North Park Lake was approximately 75 acres and its depth was approximately 24 feet near the dam face. At that time, the watershed surrounding North Park Lake generally consisted of rural agricultural fields, pastures and isolated woodlots.
As the process of uninhibited urbanization progressed outward from the City of Pittsburgh, the landscape began to change. As development around the park continues to progress, forest cover and vegetated riparian buffers along streams are being removed and soils are being disturbed and covered instead by residential and commercial buildings, roads and parking lots.
Uncontrolled surface runoff carrying sediment to the lake from residential and commercial development in the Pine Creek basin in the mid to late 20th Century has resulted in a loss of 12 acres of open water and a loss of about half of the lake’s original depth. Due to enrichment from the excessive runoff, the lake has become eutrophic (low oxygen levels) and has seen an undesired increase in aquatic macrophyte (algae) growth. These factors have not only reduced the size of the original lake but also severely degraded the remaining aquatic habitat. For example, a shallower lake results in warmer water with less oxygen which in turn results in less variety of fish and other aquatic species. If nothing is done to improve the degradation caused by excessive sedimentation, the lake will eventually fill-in completely and become wetlands, and then a meadow. This will result in a loss of open water habitat and the ability to fish in the lake.

For a complete review of this project go here: Welcome to the Pittsburgh District



The project was put out on bid; Charles J. Merlo won the bid by bidding to do the project for four million dollars. Below is the job spec sheet.


Project: North Park Lake Aquatic Ecosystem Restoration Project - Section 206

USACE - Pittsburgh District

Sponsor: Allegheny County, PA

Total Projected Cost: $16 million

Federal Portion: $5 million - capped

Contracts: Phase I Sediment Removal - Federal Contract

Charles J. Merlo - $4 million base - Includes:
75,000 cy of sediment removal (North Fork Arm)
Diversion Channels, Fish Habitat, Shoreline Plantings

Options for additional 75,000 cy of removal
Site Preparation Contract - Allegheny County
Allison Park Contractors, Inc.

Site preparation, fill management and wetland protection barrier
Phase II Sediment Removal - Allegheny County

Bids opened 5/26/10 Low Bidder - Merlo
165,000 cy of sediment removal (Pine Creek Arm)
Fish Habitat Placement

Options for additional 75,000 cy of removal
Total Sediment Removal - 315,000 cy

Status: Phase I sediment removal ongoing.

35,000 cubic yards of sediment removed as of 7/23/10
Site preparation work completed.


Wildwood Disposal Site near completion.

Project Completion: Work in the lake to be completed and lake allowed to refill in May 2011.

Website: Welcome to the Pittsburgh District

Project Update Sheet

North Park Lake Aquatic Ecosystem Restoration Project
23-Jul-10

Could this be another, low bid by a private company and then demanding more Tax Dollars to complete the job for which they were hired? Either way it looks like the Company has some expensive repair work before they can finish. Someone better hurry, May 2011 is coming quickly.
 
   / There's a right way and then there is the GOV. way #12  
What I still don't understand is why the machines weren't moved out when somebody noticed the water getting closer and closer. That doesn't make any sense at all. Maybe they don't work on Saturdays but please don't tell me somebody didn't see a weather forecast before leaving that equipment sitting there like that! Sometimes the things people do really make me cringe, and seeing those excavators drowning like that is one of them...
 
   / There's a right way and then there is the GOV. way #13  
I bet it was rented equipment..Tony
 
   / There's a right way and then there is the GOV. way #14  
I was wondering how any County could afford equipment like that - a Contractor makes more sense.
 
   / There's a right way and then there is the GOV. way
  • Thread Starter
#15  
Gator
you have some of the facts con grats ... however the bidding process started 3-09 after an army corp feasibility study in 1999
Dennis Gold of Dewatering sevices LLC (understand the link previously posted) " presented and demonstrated his patented "high Gravity" Dredging process to parks director Andy Baechle as an effective, less expensive, and less intrusive method of removing the sediment". Use of Gold's process would mean that the lake would not have to be drained and most of the eco system remains intact. The removed material with alot less water would be easier to relocate....which
now answers some of the other posters ... the sediment that they now were removing "Options for additional 75,000 cy of removal
Site Preparation Contract - Allegheny County
Allison Park Contractors, Inc"
had to much water in it and "Site preparation, fill management and wetland protection barrier
Phase II Sediment Removal - Allegheny County"
shut the General down I believe a little b4 thanksgiving ... DUH equipment is in duh mud over the weekend

The Gold method being a "patented" proven process (think Palm island ,UAE ,Dubi) was not given ,I believe "an allowable bid" even though he was competitive. The "GOV". awarded the contracts
ak9
 
   / There's a right way and then there is the GOV. way #16  
NORTH PARK LAKE:

North Park Lake: located in Hampton, McCandless and Pine Townships, Allegheny County, Pennsylvania was created by Allegheny County in the 1920痴. The signature piece of this 3,010 acre county park is its lake. North Park Lake is a man-made lake at the confluence of Pine Creek and the North Fork of Pine Creek. When first constructed in 1935, the surface area of North Park Lake was approximately 75 acres and its depth was approximately 24 feet near the dam face. At that time, the watershed surrounding North Park Lake generally consisted of rural agricultural fields, pastures and isolated woodlots.
As the process of uninhibited urbanization progressed outward from the City of Pittsburgh, the landscape began to change. As development around the park continues to progress, forest cover and vegetated riparian buffers along streams are being removed and soils are being disturbed and covered instead by residential and commercial buildings, roads and parking lots.
Uncontrolled surface runoff carrying sediment to the lake from residential and commercial development in the Pine Creek basin in the mid to late 20th Century has resulted in a loss of 12 acres of open water and a loss of about half of the lake痴 original depth. Due to enrichment from the excessive runoff, the lake has become eutrophic (low oxygen levels) and has seen an undesired increase in aquatic macrophyte (algae) growth. These factors have not only reduced the size of the original lake but also severely degraded the remaining aquatic habitat. For example, a shallower lake results in warmer water with less oxygen which in turn results in less variety of fish and other aquatic species. If nothing is done to improve the degradation caused by excessive sedimentation, the lake will eventually fill-in completely and become wetlands, and then a meadow. This will result in a loss of open water habitat and the ability to fish in the lake.

For a complete review of this project go here: Welcome to the Pittsburgh District



The project was put out on bid; Charles J. Merlo won the bid by bidding to do the project for four million dollars. Below is the job spec sheet.


Project: North Park Lake Aquatic Ecosystem Restoration Project - Section 206

USACE - Pittsburgh District

Sponsor: Allegheny County, PA

Total Projected Cost: $16 million

Federal Portion: $5 million - capped

Contracts: Phase I Sediment Removal - Federal Contract

Charles J. Merlo - $4 million base - Includes:
75,000 cy of sediment removal (North Fork Arm)
Diversion Channels, Fish Habitat, Shoreline Plantings

Options for additional 75,000 cy of removal
Site Preparation Contract - Allegheny County
Allison Park Contractors, Inc.

Site preparation, fill management and wetland protection barrier
Phase II Sediment Removal - Allegheny County

Bids opened 5/26/10 Low Bidder - Merlo
165,000 cy of sediment removal (Pine Creek Arm)
Fish Habitat Placement

Options for additional 75,000 cy of removal
Total Sediment Removal - 315,000 cy

Status: Phase I sediment removal ongoing.

35,000 cubic yards of sediment removed as of 7/23/10
Site preparation work completed.


Wildwood Disposal Site near completion.

Project Completion: Work in the lake to be completed and lake allowed to refill in May 2011.

Website: Welcome to the Pittsburgh District

Project Update Sheet

North Park Lake Aquatic Ecosystem Restoration Project
23-Jul-10

Could this be another, low bid by a private company and then demanding more Tax Dollars to complete the job for which they were hired? Either way it looks like the Company has some expensive repair work before they can finish. Someone better hurry, May 2011 is coming quickly.

This whole thing sounds like an anti-development rant to me. Maybe it was a bad idea, in the first place, to try to make a lake where mother nature obviously intended a swamp to be. Who's to say it wouldn't have silted in eventually without all the 'uninhibited urbanization'? Maybe even faster..
 
   / There's a right way and then there is the GOV. way #17  
I don't know enough about this job to comment on the Gov participation but I can easily see the Gen Contractor is and is solely responsible for preservation of his equipment owned or leased. An experienced contractor doesn't leave all his equipment parked in the bottom of a lake during a long Holiday weekend. I would also add that if this was originally thought of as a 16 million dollar project and this contractor came in at 4 million he has a lot to learn.
 
   / There's a right way and then there is the GOV. way #18  
When first constructed in 1935...the watershed surrounding North Park Lake generally consisted of rural agricultural fields, pastures and isolated woodlots.

As development around the park continues to progress, forest cover and vegetated riparian buffers along streams are being removed and soils are being disturbed and covered instead by residential and commercial buildings, roads and parking lots.
Uncontrolled surface runoff carrying sediment to the lake from residential and commercial development in the Pine Creek basin in the mid to late 20th Century has resulted in a loss of 12 acres of open water and a loss of about half of the lake痴 original depth.

Who believes that there was NOT sediment runoff from agricultural fields in 1935? Today's contour plowing and "no till" agriculture did not exist then and I'll bet there was more sediment runoff from the agricultural use then than from parking lots and subdivisions now.

I have to agree, this is not a government fault, it's the contractor.
 
   / There's a right way and then there is the GOV. way #19  
Government, private contractor or mickey mouse, that is just plain incompetent.
 
   / There's a right way and then there is the GOV. way #20  
This whole thing sounds like an anti-development rant to me. Maybe it was a bad idea, in the first place, to try to make a lake where mother nature obviously intended a swamp to be. Who's to say it wouldn't have silted in eventually without all the 'uninhibited urbanization'? Maybe even faster..

I'm with you on the pro central planning slant of the press release. I'm still waiting for someone to show me an example of the government doing ANYTHING better than private enterprise.

On the other hand, perhaps this was one of those elusive "shovel ready" projects our deal leader kept promoting
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2014 FREIGHTLINER CASCADIA MID ROOF SLEEPER (A54607)
2014 FREIGHTLINER...
1067 (A53342)
1067 (A53342)
2021 GMC SIERRA CREW CAB TRUCK (A51406)
2021 GMC SIERRA...
2014 INTERNATIONAL 7400 SBA 42 LUBE TRUCK (A51406)
2014 INTERNATIONAL...
12in x 16.5in Kubota RTV-X1140 Tires (A52377)
12in x 16.5in...
2003 Big Tex 10PI 16ft. T/A Pipe Top Utility Trailer (A52377)
2003 Big Tex 10PI...
 
Top