jcmseven
Veteran Member
I have had both on a 3000 series tractor (the same one) and my experience is this: the R1 tires definitely give better pulling traction, but the difference is not huge, just notable. They look funny to me as I agree they are too thin. I would like for JD to offer a 1-2" wider front and rear R1 option. With a loader bucket full of gravel on a firm surface, the R1's notably distorted in front. They also do not hold as much ballast due to their lower volume, so one must compensate with ballast either in wheel weights or three-point ballast. The R4's on my terrain offer about 80% the traction of the R1's when pulling; they do not distort under heavy bucket loads, they do look better to me, and they wear better and hold more ballast. They get no where near the grip in thick mud (which I do not have to excess) as the R1 tires. To me, these facts, combined with the limited trade-in options on the R1's, led me to get the R4's. Sometimes I wish for the additional grip when pulling heavy three-point attachments, but my tractor has never NOT done something I wanted it to do with the R4's. I like the R1 tire, just for most of us, it truly is not the best option.
John M
John M