Going to be purchasing a truck in the near future, and after that possibly a trailer or two. Is a 1500 grade truck (V-8) adequate to pull a 20 ft camper trailer? How about 8x16 enclosed utility trailer with 2 or 3 motorcycles inside? Or do I have to get a 2500?
Thanks
it's probably going to come down to a question of how far, how often, and at what speeds? i've had 1/2 tons and 3/4 tons for towing similar sized needs, and my experience has been that it can be done fine with the 1/2 ton, but it generally feels better behind the 3/4 ton. heavier suspension to handle the added tongue weight and bigger axles with more appropriate gear ratios for heavy loads.
assuming you equip the 1/2 ton correctly: trailer brakes and an appropriate hitch, then it can be done fine. if you plan on a lot of towing, such as seeing the country in your retirement years, or hauling the bikes every weekend, it might not be the best choice. for occasional trips, like hauling the camper to the campground and parking it there for the season, then it's probably fine.
today's 1/2 tons have pretty powerful engine choices, but don't let that fool you into thinking they are as good for towing. once you are up to speed, you don't really notice the trailer much. it's when you have to make a sudden turn, avoid an obstacle, or stop fast that i have seen the difference. the heavier duty truck seems to handle those conditions better.
the tradeoff will come when the trailer isn't there. lower fuel economy all the time and a harsher ride. initial cost shouldn't be much different - assuming you can actually compare apples to apples and find identical trim level 1/2 and 3/4 ton trucks, i can't imagine the difference is more than $500-$1000.
