Trailer winch vs recovery winch - what is difference

   / Trailer winch vs recovery winch - what is difference #1  

RobertN

Super Member
Joined
Apr 6, 2000
Messages
8,480
Location
Shingle Springs California
Tractor
New Holland TC40D
I ordered the Superwinch S7500 that was mentioned in a previous thread.

Then I got to thinking, what is the difference between a trailer winch and a recovery winch? I told a friend about the Superwinch deal; they asked the same question.

What is the difference?
 
   / Trailer winch vs recovery winch - what is difference #2  
My understanding is that a recovery winch is intended to be vehicle mounted for self-recovery of a stuck vehicle where as a trailer winch would be mounted to the trailer to pull a vehicle up on to the bed. Recovery winches are normally much heavier due to the added stress of moving a stuck vehicle, where a trailer winch is moving (usually) a rolling object.
 
   / Trailer winch vs recovery winch - what is difference #3  
Pretty much as FRUG said, recovery is for STUCK, them or you and usually plays at the 8000++++ lb level, trailer stuff is for pulling rolling stock upon a trailer like your tractor or buggy, wreckers will have a recovery winch as they often need to pull up a wrecked rig and the wheels are missing or not turning etc...
 
   / Trailer winch vs recovery winch - what is difference #4  
Many "trailer winch" ratings, are for "rolling" loads, NOT stuck loads..."stuck loads" are MUCH higher...

DM
 
   / Trailer winch vs recovery winch - what is difference #5  
On my first open deck trailer, I installed a ~12,000# winch. It was way over kill.

On my other flatbed I put just a ~4000# ATV type winch. It has pulled what ever I've hooked to it. Dragged up an ol jeep frame / body with no axles.

On trailers, I'd be happy with smaller or lower rated winches.

On my longer open deck, I welded on a round pipe at the end of the deck. That way the winch cable "rides" on the curve of the pipe when pulling up low slung rides.

I also keep a small towel to set on winch cable. Safety, to allow a snapped loaded cable to fall down to ground. Snatch block, to increase pulling power. Multi type hooks, to allow connection options. ~3ft straps with loops (Axle Straps). Different styles of shackles. I have secure mount on the rear of the trailer for a pulley, so I can loop the winch cable as to pull stuff off the trailer.

Also, keep in mind the Winch is not a method used to secure a load. That is, if you pull a car up, and just keep the winch connected with no other front securing. That is not safe to do. I see it every once in awhile, mostly on tow trucks.
 
   / Trailer winch vs recovery winch - what is difference #6  
A recovery winch also has a 100% duty cycle, well, if it's ran off hydraulics.

I'd love to put a hydraulic winch on my Dodge, but good lord, they are several thousand dollars! Plus a pump, lines, electrical, etc etc.

I also like installing a swivel hook at the end. Most of these winches come with a fixed hook.
 
   / Trailer winch vs recovery winch - what is difference #7  
pay extra car to "cable diameter" every winch can use multiple size diameter cables. thicker diameter cable = less length of cable you can put on a winch, and wind it all the way up.

besides cable, there are some that will also accept straps.

different cables have different ratings. high priced small diameter cable with more strength = vs cheaper larger diameter cable with less strength.

cables need to be taken care of, they can get dinged up, and begin to come apart / unravel. some may want to rust up, and/or from just usage get all dusted up and dirty.

check the gearing on winches, some are really big motor no gearing, and some are smaller motor with a lot of gearing to get to desired pull amount.

winches themselves making a hand crank, to a hand crank with 12v motor, to 12v motor, they all look the same to me with standard "mounting" so you can swap out a mount for front of vehicle, to rear of vehicle, to hitch mount, to trailer mount, to tractor mount, to a boat mount, to other. some winch mounts are directly built so you can pull the winch on/off so you can toss it into shed say during week, and then what you go out you can toss winch onto the truck/trailer.

some winches have "brakes" for example you are lifting up a load vertically say on a crane, you do not want the load to come falling down. so there be a brake, same for say a boat winch, you do not want to pull a boat up on a trailer, and then watch the boat slide back into the water.

from what i have seen, most manufactures offer some sort of "wireless remote" package, something like a keychain to lock/unlock vehicle or start vehicle. but for operating winch. honestly trying to deal with 20 plus feet of cable for a remote control can be a bit of a pain. but at least you should be able to stand behind a door of a vehicle or something, so in case cable breaks, it does not chop you in half.

grainger.com, harborfreight.com, northerntool.com check all 3 places, they normally list enough winches to help get an idea of ratings and specifications.
 
   / Trailer winch vs recovery winch - what is difference #8  
I don't think there is much difference. Superwinch claims their trailer winches have a better brake mechanism that includes "soft" actuation for less of a jolt, and is capable of more frequent pulls before overheating, but I don't know if that is achieved primarily by the construction or by derating the pull. Either way the housing design is nice if you don't need a big pull rating.
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2025 Swict 78in Bucket Skid Steer Attachment (A44571)
2025 Swict 78in...
2017 FREIGHTLINER CASCADIA TANDEM AXLE SLEEPER (A43004)
2017 FREIGHTLINER...
Toro Groundsmaster 3500D Mower (A44391)
Toro Groundsmaster...
Dixie Chopper Silver Eagle 2744 (A44501)
Dixie Chopper...
2007 Chevrolet Suburban 2500 4x4 (MPV), VIN # 3GNGK26K47G305799 (A44391)
2007 Chevrolet...
Wacker RT Walk behind Trench Compactor (A44391)
Wacker RT Walk...
 
Top