I built the flat thumb cuz it was easier. The excavator
thumb I operated on a rental machine was flat, too. It seems
to help holding dirt in the bucket. I had no problems gripping
logs. The toplink endures much less stress in this application
than it does using a box blade with rippers. The weak point
will be your dipper stick, since the steel is not real thick. Also
mild steel wears very fast with rock handling.