Weed wacker - extending string life

   / Weed wacker - extending string life #151  
It's not that they get dull, they get short, since they're plastic they wear down.

Also those worried about safety, I weedwack in flip flops, and in 5 years never had one come off. Their locking mechanism is solid.
It's not the plastic I am worried about, it's the small rocks and thorns that hit my shoes while using the trimmer that make me wear boots, even with the shield on.
 
   / Weed wacker - extending string life #152  
I tried whippering in shorts and sneakers once and once only. My legs looked like I had a fight and lost to a bunch of hornets. My next door neighbour was trimming without glasses on, I gave her an earful and a spare pair I had.....some people.
 
   / Weed wacker - extending string life #153  
It's not the plastic I am worried about, it's the small rocks and thorns that hit my shoes while using the trimmer that make me wear boots, even with the shield on.
Yeah I always have to remind myself not to wear shorts when weed wacking. Otherwise my legs end up looking like they were attacked by stinging wasps from all of the stone hits.
 
   / Weed wacker - extending string life #154  
I tried whippering in shorts and sneakers once and once only. My legs looked like I had a fight and lost to a bunch of hornets. My next door neighbour was trimming without glasses on, I gave her an earful and a spare pair I had.....some people.
Man... that's crazy! Feet are one thing, but I get whacked in the face or safety glasses with something coming off the trimmer several times every year! I'm sure I'd be blind by now, if I ran that thing all these years without glasses.

I weed whack in shorts, but they're longer Carhaart duck work shorts, and I wear logging boots (stylish, eh?). So the actual amount of leg exposed is probably only 8" centered on my knee, and it doesn't bother me at all.
 
   / Weed wacker - extending string life #155  
Sort of. Yes the line is nylon and more specifically either a Nylon 6 or a 6/6 (has to do with the precursor chemicals used to make the polymer). These are both very common, high volume materials (read: cheap) and are also inherently very hygroscopic. That is true of many but not all nylons, but given the huge volumes of 6/6 in particular, if that is what you think of when you hear "nylon," odds are quite high you are right. Nylon has a lot of great properties, but moisture absorption can be a mixed bag as it can help in some situations and hurt a lot in others.

6/6 fully saturated holds about 6% water by volume, but fully saturated is not terribly common as it typically takes submersion for several days. But that looks to be what people are talking about here. Water in 6/6 acts very much like a plasticizer. Think of a vinyl 3-ring binder or document sleeve. This is PVC with a ton of plasticizers in it (often chemicals called phthalates) to make it flexible. PVC pipe is the same material but lacking those plasticizers so it is rigid. Well that is basically what water does to 6/6. That is why the line get less brittle and more flexible when soaked. It also greatly improves the impact strength of the material

But again, 6/6 loves water. It soaks it up from the atmosphere and will easily get up to a couple percent water in it in humid summer air. This is a bigger issue for those in very arid climates where the nylon can get quite dry.

This also shows up in injection molding. To mold nylon, you first have to dry all the moisture out of it, or it hurts the material properties. But freshly molded nylon parts can be sensitive to impact. This condition is called DAM (dry as molded) and is often listed on data sheets along with a couple other moisture levels (like 3% and fully saturated) to give you a feel for how moisture affects its properties. A coworker told a story from a previous job where they were molding nylon parts, putting a handful in a bag, sealing it up and shipping it and the customer was getting them already broken from shipping. He told them to put a teaspoon of water in the bag before sealing. No water was left in the bag when the customer got them but also no more breakage!

Probably more than you wanted to know (if you didn't fall asleep), but that is a summary of the science behind it.

Here's an example chart for Nylon 6, showing how it reduces tensile strength and modulus (makes it less stiff - aka softer) but also improves the Impact strength by a factor of 3 at the same time. It says in the website that this 50% RH air results in about 2% moisture.

View attachment 3873416
So this verifies my wet string test? I placed some in water for a few days, then while using them in a 3 or 4 string heads alongside dry ones I marked them as they were replaced but started with all new one. Then as they broke and while others still looked good, was only replaced them as needed. Dry vers wet made no difference in longevity.

Question, why don't them make strings from HDPE or LDPE or some poly that is flexible enough?
 
   / Weed wacker - extending string life #156  
So, for those of us who load string into a trimmer just a few times per year... how long does soaked string retain its advantage? I mean, if the thing is sitting for weeks in a shed after spooling it onto the trimmer head, isn't it just going to return to its formerly-dry state after a short time?
 
   / Weed wacker - extending string life #158  
So, for those of us who load string into a trimmer just a few times per year... how long does soaked string retain its advantage? I mean, if the thing is sitting for weeks in a shed after spooling it onto the trimmer head, isn't it just going to return to its formerly-dry state after a short time?
I just don’t see how you only load string a few times a year. I have to reload a few times a weekend.
 
   / Weed wacker - extending string life #159  
So this verifies my wet string test? I placed some in water for a few days, then while using them in a 3 or 4 string heads alongside dry ones I marked them as they were replaced but started with all new one. Then as they broke and while others still looked good, was only replaced them as needed. Dry vers wet made no difference in longevity.

Question, why don't them make strings from HDPE or LDPE or some poly that is flexible enough?
Nylon is a great polymer. Very strong, tough, heat resistant and holds up to a lot of common chemicals, plus pretty cheap to make. The polyolefins like HDPE, LDPE are no where near as strong (though they are cheap and very chemical resistant). But...chemical resistance is not a big selling point for trimmer string. I doubt they would hold up in this application due to strength and temp.
 
   / Weed wacker - extending string life #160  
I just don’t see how you only load string a few times a year. I have to reload a few times a weekend.
Grass ain't that tough! :p

Each spring, I run a bed definer around each of my flower beds, which total nearly an acre. Probably something close to 2000 linear feet of edging. I follow this with the string trimmer on the "mulch" side of that edging, blasting out all the little tufts of grass that have crossed the line from lawn into garden, and simultaneously breaking up and scattering all the edger waste into the garden, before scattering fresh mulch into the gardens. During the few weekends that takes, I will go thru a lot of trimmer line, reloading several times in just a few weeks.

But then I can go the rest of the season with reloading probably less than once per month, since I'm only cutting grass, weeds, and raspberry shoots with the stuff, not trees!
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2008 Ford F-250 Knapheide Service Truck (A50323)
2008 Ford F-250...
2012 RAM 5500 (A52472)
2012 RAM 5500 (A52472)
UNUSED FUTURE MINI EXCAVATOR HEDGE CUTTER (A51244)
UNUSED FUTURE MINI...
2011 CATERPILLAR M318D MOBILE EXCAVATOR (A51242)
2011 CATERPILLAR...
2003 JOHN DEERE 350D OFF ROAD DUMP (A51242)
2003 JOHN DEERE...
(4) Texas Built 25' Stand Alone Panels (A50515)
(4) Texas Built...
 
Top