What is yalls opinion on craftsman hand tools??

   / What is yalls opinion on craftsman hand tools?? #21  
Hey JR, Bird - I've been out for a couple days playing with wood, and tractors. I'm tempted to elaborate, 'cause the wood is walnut I thought was gonna be firewood, and the tractor is my neighbors' new L4330 (to be delivered in 1-1/2 weeks) with cool implements, but I gotta stick to the subject at hand.

A couple things JR: I think the subject of advanced mechanics is really cool. I specifically dig machine shop type technology, and someday I want learn more about the subject. I want to set up a couple tools I have stuck in the garage to do projects like rechambering rifle barrels and such. Even though I am ignorant of the specifics, I am right with ya when you talk about aircraft subjects. Your picture of the yellow engine hanging off your bucket is one I still go look at once in while. In fact, not to belabor the point, but I was planning to go into the Navy before I got enough loans and grants to go to college. I was going to pursue aviation mechanics, and either make it a career in the service, or come out and try to work for an airport or aircraft manufacturer. So I'm totally with you on the points you make regarding the demands and specialized tools and techniques required for aircraft work. But I think the conversation about 6pt vs 12 pt and what's junk and what's not is a little misleading to anyone who is new to this, and even to me, since I am trying to learn as much as I can and not just assume I know things - even simple things like the proper sockets to use. In fact, I took your comments about thicker walls with 6 pts to be a positive thing, and it's why I bought them over the years, and why I use them everywhere I can. My experience is I have less round over and less nut damage in higher torque situations. Which is what you implied 6 pts are for - higher torque situations. So on this tractor board, I think you make a good case for using 6 pts, even though your points about more delicate fasteners are well made. ("My, what delicate fasteners you have, Grandmother!" /forums/images/graemlins/tongue.gif)

A properly maintained fastener will respond as well to a 12 pt as a 6.....chasing threads with a tap or die to clean them up, using anti seize vs oil on threads, etc....proper torque, i.e. bolt stretch.......another subject entirely.

Now, regarding gear wrenches, thank you for clarifying the difference....I thought they were all the same, even the reversing ones. It seems the ones you say are better turn in one direction, and are "reversed" by flipping the wrench over - I think even I can handle that.

Finally, it wasn't me talking about 6 vs 12 pts, it was bgott, but I'll take the heat. He makes good points, but we can go on about this forever, because we're looking at it from two different perspectives. I also work on automotive and not aircraft stuff, so my 12 pts stay in the tray - but that doesn't mean you are of unsure parentage because you use them, JR /forums/images/graemlins/shocked.gif /forums/images/graemlins/shocked.gif /forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif

Happy Easter to all
 
   / What is yalls opinion on craftsman hand tools?? #22  
Hmmm, 12pt vs 6 pt. Well, the 6pt just sit in my box /forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif. I rarely have use for them even on the tractor, lawnmower or auto. Autos and motorcycles in particular have a lot of close bolts and nuts that are so close to a flange or whatever that I find myself shaving down a socket to just get on them. No, I don't shave a Snapon but I have a complete set of shaved Craftsman sockets. True, 6 pt are good for higher torques but in most cases guys way over torque bolts. Most engine bolts and even other stuff if you look for the torque spec is actually fairly low. Running wheel nuts on with an air wrench, spark plugs and a few other areas do require a 6 point perhaps. I sure would hate having to use a 6 pt combo wrench--that would be a drag, sockets aren't so bad because the ratchet mechanism determines the swing arc. Thick walls on sockets are an indication of poor quality whether 6 pt or 12 pt. I have a set of sockets from SK that have a positive relief on the grip end--not rebatted and they are very thin wall, They go almost anywhere. I don't mean to lead folks astray, I just don't think much of 6 pt tools, especially combo wrenches, close ends and etc. You know what I really hate is having to maintain multiple sets of tools for metric, USA and Old English (I forget the standard--off hand but it is different from US fractional, SAE fractional).
I guess that once you go above say 3/4 size bolts the 6 pt begins to make sense in terms of torque requirements but below that, nah /forums/images/graemlins/smirk.gif. Who needs a wrench or socket that can apply 1,000 in/lb to a 3/8 fastener when 40-60 is more typical and when you consider the swing arc of a 12 pt wrench is half that of a 6 pt you are giving up flexibility for what /forums/images/graemlins/crazy.gif? Maybe we need a Toolbynet.com. There is no limit to tool requirements /forums/images/graemlins/shocked.gif. When I got married I was just a kid fresh out of school and all I had was a drill, a hammer and a saw. Now I could outfit a semi truck with tools and you know what, I simply don't have enough tools /forums/images/graemlins/grin.gif. I need a Bridgeport and a larger TIG and a plasma cutter and an English wheel ---------- /forums/images/graemlins/frown.gif , so you see, I have moved well beyond 6 vs 12 pt, I just bought them all. J
 
   / What is yalls opinion on craftsman hand tools?? #23  
Yeah, like that.......

Actually, if I discover, as it seems I am, that I can use the 12 pts again and not risk nut damage (......nah, I'll let that go /forums/images/graemlins/blush.gif), then maybe I will. I guess I never really thought it over, and I have had some tight fits here and there. Maybe also I favor 6 pt because my craftsman 12 pts aren't all that good, tolerance wise.

Does sound like we need more tools, huh?
 
   / What is yalls opinion on craftsman hand tools?? #25  
Whitworth, YES, thanks, I remembered it shortly after I posted. I actually have a set given me by my grandfather. He was a self made engineer and designed various types of machinery for--well--I need not go there since it was a sore subject till his last day but anyway, he used them for steam engines which drove the "undefined" machinery I mentioned. Apparently these steam engines had an odd collection of fasteners. These tools and several other custom wrenches were made for him by a tool company that bears our last name but which is only related to us distantly in the family tree.
I really do hate the metric system for tools. It is a wonderful system for science and engineering and scientific measurements but for mechanical systems I prefer the fractional scale including for my tools. Just me and lot's of other people. I would almost quit driving Toyotas and even consider a GM product /forums/images/graemlins/shocked.gifagain if they would dump the metric system. J
 
   / What is yalls opinion on craftsman hand tools??
  • Thread Starter
#26  
Well i went to sears today and they had the sears version gear wrench on sale for 49$$ I couldn't decide between the gear wrench and the craftsman. The gr one had two more wrencxhes, 8 versus 5 for craf. Well what made up my mind was that the craftsman are exchanged right there if they break, and the gear wrench must be sent off.. So i got them and i love them. I am proably going to have to invest in a metric set.. So now i am getting a pretty nice tool set up.

Thanks guys!!
 

Tractor & Equipment Auctions

2011 Mack CHU613 T/A Wet Kit Day Cab Truck Tractor (A51692)
2011 Mack CHU613...
2022 New Holland Workmaster 120 MFWD Compact Utility Tractor (A52748)
2022 New Holland...
2022 Down2Earth 82in x 36ft Two-Car Hauler (A52748)
2022 Down2Earth...
2013 FREIGHTLINER CORNADO (INOPERABLE) (A52472)
2013 FREIGHTLINER...
2019 INTERNATIONAL LT625 (A52472)
2019 INTERNATIONAL...
Komatsu PC56 Excavator (A51573)
Komatsu PC56...
 
Top