4570Man
Super Star Member
- Joined
- Apr 7, 2015
- Messages
- 18,257
- Location
- Crossville, TN
- Tractor
- Kubota M59, Kubota L3800, Grasshopper 428D, Topkick dump truck, 3500 dump truck, 10 ton trailer, more lighter trailers.
Did you bother to watch the videos? These mowers are used in heavy brush, exactly where they shine. A skidsteer spends more time ramping the mower speed up, only to slow down again on the next hit again.
We're used to operate the tractors in tight spaces so we probably work around it just fine. If there is an area that's big enough to be a field, then it's either a pasture or used to grow something. So it's not that people here is mowing huge fields either.
A fully shielded tractor with forestry tires and a heavy duty brush mower with two rotors with 4 chains per rotor will be quite a bit cheaper than a skidsteer with a brush mower, plus it can move in between jobs without an extra hauling equipment, while still operating at a third or less of a cost of the skidsteer. A 75HP tractor mowing brush here, will cost about $75 to $100/hour. What would a skidsteer cost? $350/hour if I remember correctly from a couple threads here? And would take more time than the tractor to do the same job.
If the skidsteer would be that much superior, trust me, we would be all over it in my country because we do value our hard earned money very well, yet the skidsteers seem to stay in the construction business.
As far as looking backwards, you'll look backwards quite a bit on a skidsteer as well, unless you like hitting whatever it's behind you. Part of operating a tractor, is actually looking backwards. Not sure why this is a big deal. We seem to survive just fine over here.
Two rotors on this one to reduce the overall length of it:
Yes I watched the videos. The side panels, fuel tank and the cab glass is still mostly unprotected. I wasn’t able to see about the belly shields. But a tractors belly isn’t exactly durable where the skid steer has a complete belly pan. You can probably hire a skid steer mulcher for $150-200 an hour. Virtually nobody has shielded tractors with tree cutting mowers over here to compare to buy it’s a safe bet they’re not running them for $75 an hour. The power company has a few heavy shielded tractors with brown brush cutters is virtually the only ones I’ve ever seen in person. But this whole discussion didn’t really matter. The OP isn’t going to try to turn his tractor into a forestry machine when he already has the skid steer. And if we want to go down the what’s better road a dedicated mulcher is better than either other option by a long shot. I’m not that that big of a fan of mulching anyway. It’s good for ROW maintenance but for field clearing dozers and excavators are the best way IMO.