Depends on the solenoid, but I used to take the one on my 72 Chevy Blazer apart and clean its contacts; not too hard. (It was built into the starter mtor.)
Going back to California's tests-- another easier way to do a quick starter motor check is to turn headlights on and see if they dim when the key's switched to "start."
Starter motors draw a ton of amps, and if it's getting juice, the lights will dim significantly. No dimming means the motor's not sucking any juice, so you start tracing the ignition circuit, beginning with solenoid.
Good luck!
Thanks thats a good tip I missed. I will do that and see what happens.
From what you have written I would say that your problem is the solenoid (or the connection to it), Make sure you have a good connection to the solenoid from the switch and if that does not do it, take the solenoid off. If it comes apart then clean the contacts, if not then you may be able to just replace it. Inside will be two terminal contacts, a spring and a disk attached to a shaft that is pulled by the electric magnet coil. The coil draws the shaft until the disk hits both contacts (battery and starter motor), [if either contact has a small tit, that may be enough to keep the disk from contacting the second contact.] The mechanical movement of the shaft and disk also moves the starter bendix into engagement with the flywheel. By tapping on the solenoid you are moving the disk slightly so that the "tit" falls into a depression and therefore allowing the solenoid to make contact--or jiggles the shaft which may be binding in the coil.
Just a brief definition of what is going on inside where you cannot see.And an explanation of what may be happening.
Mike
Wow great explanation! thanks I will recheck connection at solenoid, test lights for dim on start ect. then try to clean it or replace. I Didnt get a chance to work on It today... thanks again EVERYONE for the help!