TSO
Elite Member
I agree... when I was shopping for my current tractor, I went up 2 sizes. Was only going to go up 1 size (similar to a jump from a 'B' series to the 'L3800' size) and decided I should go up 1 more to not regret the purchase. I'm sure glad I did because I wouldn't have been as happy with the smaller size. Like I said before, tractors shrink EXTREMELY FAST once you get some seat-time on them. And actually, if I could have gone just a touch bigger but kept HST, then I might have done it. Like you say, once you get used to it, you really can't notice the difference in maneuverability. Naturally, a bigger tractor will ALWAYS be more cumbersome than a smaller one, just plain physics there. Harder to fit into tree'd areas, harder to maneuver and turn in tight spaces, etc.When I went from the Bobcat CT235 to the Kubota L4240 (both are similar in size as to what is being discussed) I could not tell I am on a larger tractor as far as maneuverability. The turning radius is actually better on the Kubota.
A friend of mine pointed out that he could technically do everything with his previous B2920, as he now can with his L3540. But the difference is the time, convenience, and overall usability. Someone brought up "renting" larger equipment when the need arises. If that's the case, why not just get a BX sized Kubota, smaller implements, and rent the bigger tractor when needed? Why bother even getting the L3800 if it's not going to handle all your chores anyhow?
I still maintain (as others have pointed out) that if you're planning to do hay work, the L3800 (just like my 47hp rig) will not be big enough to handle it. If not for the hay work (including moving bales around) then the L3800 would probably be able to handle most of the work. 38hp is enough to power a 6' cutter, so you can do your brush-hogging. But, if you need to have a strong loader for loader work (and as GmanBart pointed out) you may find that you max out the loader capabilities often. I found that to be true with my previous small tractor, and I still find it now when digging stumps. Stepping up to the next series, or even the l4200 or something... can up your loader specs. Get the MX4700/5100, or the L4240/60 (I think you can get the LA854 loader with that) and you'll really step up in loader strength, WHILE keeping a relatively small footprint.
Again, better to have it and not need it, than need it and not have it. Some people have brought up "right-sizing" your equipment. Well I 100% agree with the concept, but not their logic. If it's not the right size to handle everything you need/want it to do, and you have to rent a bigger unit to do something (again not including specialty equipment) then it's NOT right-sized !